Reviews for -FREE WHISTLE POINTS-

[Isledeavarice]

I dis-agree

Newgrounds is for the public - its not just for people who make flash movies. A film critic has the right to write crappy reviews for movies even if they couldn't direct a better one, therefore anyone on this site who wants to trash a movie can, even if they are not a flash maker.

I am a flash maker, and I don't have a problem with people 0-ing my stuff if they honestly think its bad even if they don't make flash.

Are you saying that people who don't make flash don't have the right to review, or that they should only write positive reviews?

If people think its good, you get good reviews. If people think its bad, they trash it and have the right to.

Only exceptions are those who just go around watching the first five seconds and then voting 5 or zero based on that to get lots and lots of points. Those people I do have a problem with. But if people watch the whole thing to the end, and honestly think its bad, and vote 0 - thats fair, wether there flash makers or not.

[Rookar]

RESPOND PLS. I kinda agree and kinda dont :P

-=RESPOND PLS=-

hiya, first off i must say that i kinda agree with your main point. There are so many STUPID reviews out there! and i know cuz i got a few submittions ;) (not on this account)

but! i think 1 of the things you said are not true, i think a man that never made a flash movie actually CAN help you, i dont think reviews are about to tell you how to do everything, they are also about telling u wuts wrong.

like saying "Make more violence" that isnt really helpfull.. no not really :P BUT atleast you know that someone out there likes violence so you know that in your next flash you should maybe consider having more violenece. if you know wut i mean :P

but i TOTALLY agree with EVERYTHING else!

and here are a few tips for episode 2!

- please dont use speakonia, get voice actors or sumthing from the "Voice actors club" or wutever its called! and you can always get sum from the BBS.. i think :P! and if you still want to use speakonia maybe you should add subtitles at the buttom. maybe :P im not saying you have to..

- Make everyone understand more rules, cuz the way i see it.. this is REALLY helpfull for assholes :D! but you only said how to make reviews helpfull.. i think :P anyways show everyone sum more rules please.... im not saying you have to..

I think everything else is really great and helpfull :D

I know im "a part of the problem" and you'll probably not consider this review helpfull but i dont really care. i made this review to help you with the next episode! (if you'll make 1)

You'll probably show everyone how wrong i am and how write you are, but before you do.. im just gonna ask you to go easy on me lol.. im just a dumb 13 years old kid, Dont expect me to be as "smart" as you are. once again, im not saying you have to..

Well thats it, and good luck showing the assholes how dumb they really are :D

P.S. You might also say "omg omg you just showed everyone your a moron LOLZERXS" but i dont care :/ just trying to help you.. you know :P

[halomaster985]

i thought it was pretty good

yo mushroom pm me i wanna tell u something

[Doomsquirrel]

hmmmmm interesting

maybe you should respond to some reviews saying..

"That review sucked, Try Harder"

cause they can't criticize you for not being a good reviewer, now can they...ingrateful bastards...the whole lot of em...

keep up the good work...
and by all means, try harder

[PhoenixLL]

My biggest review yet?

Hmmm
Well in this case, i´ll take both side if this matter

What i agree :
Yes there are a lot of crappy reviews that don´t offer anything at all than just mostly "You suck", "This movie sucks dick" or "You are just a fag".
And there are worser kind of them to like, "ASFADGFADHS" and even worser with things like "..." with nothing on it, FREE POINTS??
And i agree that people can´t accept crappy animatings or flash games, such as pong in a worser version or a 15 second long flash about... errghh!! Vaginas???
And i agree that faggy people can´t judge of what they THINK is crap beacuse they have never ever animated or EVEN painted anything as good as everyone doing mostly on newgrounds...
Pros and amateurs alike, they do their best to become a famous flash animator or a Game flash animator...
i have never produced any flash myself, but i am fair (SOMETIMES) when it comes to somewhere around "CRAP" and "BAD"
But as i was before, i was banned in 5 or 6 months beacuse i wrote horrible reviews... and i changed that mind and become of what newground user i am today...

But you got a lot of things i disagree :
I know it´s not fair to vote low just to get "FREE" Blam points but you can´t vote high just to get "FREE" Save points either, it´s their decision (Spell error) to make whatever kind of review they want to or their point/score to give the flash, BY THEMSELVES, you can´t ASK for FREE points to get higher rating of your flash animating by doing something that possibly "Amateur flash users" can do and talk against them and scream "Go and fuck yourself" beacuse you had used an idea that some writes in their reviews "I could do it to if i had flash" they are confidence of that, but they only say those words to only possibly piss you off or even worser, to give a respond with words like "Fuck you" or "Get of newgrounds, you don´t belong here".

For this flash animating, i gave everything a zero except the Overall wich i gave an eight beacuse of this :

A plot and a reminder of what newgrounds have bacome...

and so far, i think this is my biggest review on newgrounds this far..

I take neither sides...
You´re both wrong no matter how hard you tries, OR i can´t say that RIGHT and WRONG Doesn´t actually exist, beacuse the reiwer can´t just give a low score beacuse everyone else is doing so, and the Author can´t just tell people to FUCK OFF?! beacuse ha can do something wich others CANNOT?!?!?!?!?!

Oh Yeah one more things...
On the instructions you wrote for the movie, you took people that "Might" have reviewed horrible on newgrounds...
well those you have choosen are just one part of like ... 5000 other who have reviewed very unfairly or very harsch language as "Fuck off and die"

So what i think very shortly :

Yes it is wrong to review UNFAIRLY beacuse they have never touched a flash tool...

it is wrong to judge other people to change their opinion and thinks to get bigger score beacuse you´re right?

Judge me if you want, your opinion about my review counts to if you forgot :)

PhoenixLL / No the Double L does not stand for Lock Legion... i used the LL before i knew the Lock legion existed...

Happy Days for those who managed to read all this by eyes >:)