At 4/29/12 02:33 AM, HeavenDuff wrote:
At 4/28/12 03:29 PM, ElGhoulio wrote: Did I ever say metalcore was shitty? Did I ever say I was angry? Jeez, puttin' words in my mouth. I'm not angry, nor do I have a problem with metalcore (I actually know personally a metalcore band) and I never said real metal wasn't cliche' either. I'm not a stereotypical "angry metalhead" because I listen to a shit ton of non-metal (think Combichrist, KMFDM, Oomph!, Coil, Tool, Mahavishnu Orchestra, Kansas, Journey, Buckethead, etc...)Well this is what you wrote :
"If a metalcore band isn't going to make any money, it's not because metalcore isn't incessantly commercial, accessible, or mainstream. It's probably because there are OVER 9000 clones of DevilDriver, A7X, Beyond the Horizon, Job for a Cowboy, Hatebreed, etc... and the field is inundated with an oversupply." and "... if you are in a tech/crossover/hybrid/are these even genres?/whatever metalcore band than if you are, say, a black metal band, a power metal band, a doom metal band, a progressive metal band, or really any sort of metal that isn't watered down commercial pandering."
I kept both parts of your post in which you display some kind of disrespect toward the genre. And pardon me if I draw conclusions too fast, but usually the use of words like commercial and mainstream are pejorative, at least when used by people who really like music. Maybe this is what made me think that you didn't like Metalcore as a whole. Not that I disagree with you... the genre is still mainly oriented toward most commercial goals then metal. But still, I felt the need to say that it's not because you use any kind of core elements that you are systematicaly a commercial and mainstream band.
I never meant to say you were a bad person or some close-minded pissed-off metalhead. I was just referring to a typical (and still understandable) behavior of metalheads toward pretty much anything that includes "-core" elements.
I got ya, but I got sick of being tarred as a close minded metalhead right around the time I went through the phase of not liking black metal (around 2008). I have no problem with commercialism (I go to gothic industrial dance clubs a lot) as long as it's not blatant, shameless, and cloyingly dishonest commercialism. (I.e. they're TRYING to get MTV status and don't care about much else.)
Also, when I referred to "watered down metal) I was referring to bands like Metallica, Venom, Megadeth, Avantasia, and others who suck their label's cock for higher sales figures.