At 5/19/11 03:26 AM, Bahamut wrote:
I can see where you're coming from here but even so, both Keepers albums are undoubtedly power metal.
Mih, I would beg to differ.
In my opinion:
Walls Of Jericho = Undoubtedly thrash metal.
Both keeper albums = Traditional metal with power metal elements, but not really power metal. At most, it's protopower metal and even that is pushing the envelope.
Everything with Andi Deris = Hard rock with metal guitar solos and metal drumming, but that's pretty much it. I don't see why anyone would call deris era helloween power metal, or metal at all...
So pretty much, while Helloween is commonly regarded as power metal, I never once saw them as power metal. That being said, they practically inspired every power metal band ever. haha
Speaking of which, if ANYONE here doesn't own the first three helloween albums then you REALLY need to check them out. They're all brilliant, and even if you don't like them much, they're pretty important stamps on metal and worth at least knowing.
At 5/19/11 04:14 PM, HeavenDuff wrote:
I didn't say that they were a good introduction to Power Metal or that they could easily fit metalhead's tastes in general. I'm just expressing my opinion on this piece of gold that is Winterheart's Guild.
Most REAL power metal fans either hate Sonata Arctica or only like their older stuff and admit to it as being a guilty pleasure.
That being said, Sonata Arctica is a band that is both a good turn off and a good turn on for a power metal introduction. Let me explain:
To someone who listens to little-to-no metal and/or doesn't actually play any instruments, Sonata Arctica's first four(Five including the jap. only album) albums are genius and the next thing you know they'll be listening to stratovarius, nightwish and rhapsody.
BUT to someone who listens to a lot of metal, and I mean like tons of thrash or black or something, or someone who DOES in fact play an instrument - when they hear any sonata arctica they are likely to totally hate sonata arctica and be turned off of power metal for a long time.
So yeah, when introducing someone to power metal be sure to keep that in mind before recommending sonata arctica. (That's to everyone)
I'm not a big Power Metal fan myself, but these guys are absolutely amazing, and I think this one album is a gem.
Check out Silence, as both a big power metal fan and a former SA fanboy I think that's easily their best.
Maybe you'll be surprised, but I never got into Blind Guardian. I don't have any of their work in my iTunes Library and I don't think that I've listened to more then 10 songs by them in my entire life.
Here's a short rundown of each album and with a link of my favorite song off each. (Keep in mind, blind guardian is my favorite band) Read the rundowns, listen to the songs, and download one or two of the albums you think you'll enjoy the most. :)
Battalions Of Fear (1988)
Total thrash metal, or "speed metal" as some would call it. If you like exodus-esque guitar solos, almost screaming vocals and the urge to mosh and headbang - check this one out. The power metal elements on this album are almost nonexistent.
Follow The Blind (1989)
This album is still thrash metal, or "speed metal", but this album has way more traditional metal esque moments. Like galloping riffs, epic chorus's and lyrics you'd expect from a band like Iron Maiden or Raven. But it is still quite thrashtastic, especially as seen by the borderline gang vocals, the balls-to-the-wall drumming and more exodus-esque guitar solos. Also some power metal elements begin showing up, like some riffs that totally sound like they belong on a Rhapsody or Cryonic Temple album. Kai Hansen also has a guest appearance and sings in "Valhalla."
Tales From The Twilight World (1990)
Okay so this album continues the path Follow The Blind started taking, with even more traditional metal esque moments. HOWEVER, this album still has quite a bit of thrash still in it. The power metal elements don't TRULY start showing up until this album though, as in more sing along lyrics, more fantasy esque lyrics in general, and slower but more melodic drumming. Kai Hansen guest appears again and does vocals on "Lost In The Twilight Hall" and a guitar solo on the song I posted, "The Last Candle."
Somewhere Far Beyond (1992)
Some people would say that this is the first "real" blind guardian album since this is the first album where it is, indubitably, blind guardian. This album is really the first i'd consider the power metal elements more prominent then the traditional or thrash ones. The songs are epic to listen to, the lyrics are continuously getting more fantasy influenced and imaginative, the guitar solos are unmistakenably a cross between typical pm and typical tm guitar solos and the bard's song is probably the most famous power metal ballad ever recorded. While power metal, their are still enough thrash metal elements in this to make most of this album still moshable. Their are actually some early folk metal elements in this as well, mainly because of the lyrics and the guest bagpipes some of the songs had. haha Kai Hansen guest appears yet again, he does a guitar solo on "The Quest for Tanelorn."
Imaginations from the Other Side (1995)
This album was EASILY the hardest to pick a favorite song for, as every song on it is a classic tune. This is the only blind guardian album I recommend to ALL metal fans, whether it be of power metal, thrash metal or traditional metal. Sadly this album is the last album where the thrash metal roots really pierce through. I can't really describe this album, it's just... perfect. I don't even know if the song I linked is my favorite blind guardian song or not, however it was my very first blind guardian song ever so it has a special connection with me. :P
Nightfall In Middle Earth (1998)
The most successful, the most popular and easily the most critically acclaimed album: Nightfall is considered a masterpiece by most power metal fans. The epic chrous's, the entirely LOTR based lyrics and nonstop amazing guitar riffing/soloing makes most people jizz at this album. While this is the first album where you can't really hear thrash influences, this might be their most aggressive sounding album - but maybe that's because of Hansi's vocals getting heavier. Now be warned, half of the tracks are short, song interludes that really break up the songs and are meant to further the effect of the lyrics. This may or may not be a good thing, if you go to the bathroom a lot or really enjoy LOTR you might just like them. Sadly, despite everyone loving this album it's far from my favorite BG album. This album also has the ONLY Blind Gurdian song I dislike: "Nightfall."
A Night At The Opera (2002)
Epic. The only word that fully describes this album. Precious Jerusalem and Age of False Innocence aside, this album is nonstop amazing. If you are a guitar fanatic or enjoy ballsie power metal with prog elements, this album is for you. Also this album is my favorite when it comes to vocals.
A Twist In The Myth (2006)
Most peoples least favorite BG album. Basically imagine a 00's album you'd expect from a 80's band like Iron Maiden or Judas Priest and you got this album. But way more cheesy. Not bad by any means, just not special.
At The Edge Of Time (2010)
Ive listened to this album four times, Bahamut review this one. haha Lots of prog elements though, it's epic.