At 5/3/07 11:19 AM, NewShape wrote: Hey guys I have a question, is it possible for your whistle points to go down if you havent flagged in a while and have a whistle above normal?

No, your whistle stays the same if you don't use it. It will only go down if you flag incorrectly.

Look around a bit, especially on the first and second page.

http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/readreview.p hp?sort=date_mr&id=270956&page=2

A good pick here, and there will probably be more

http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/readreview.p hp3?id=376739&page=1

Lordsalem can't tell the diffrence between reviewing and PMing.

At 5/3/07 03:34 PM, Little-Rena wrote: Lordsalem can't tell the diffrence between reviewing and PMing.

this is what it said

"Hey This Game Is Not Bad Keep It Up Soz I Havent Gave It A Score No Point :P But Good Game"

At 5/3/07 04:02 PM, Cheekyvincent wrote: this is what it said

"Hey This Game Is Not Bad Keep It Up Soz I Havent Gave It A Score No Point :P But Good Game"

Indeed.
But that's no reason for an overall 0 lmao.

At 5/3/07 04:18 PM, Little-Rena wrote:

At 5/3/07 04:02 PM, Cheekyvincent wrote: this is what it said

"Hey This Game Is Not Bad Keep It Up Soz I Havent Gave It A Score No Point :P But Good Game"

Indeed.
But that's no reason for an overall 0 lmao.

Yeah, she is right. That is an unfair review it was deleted.

Can some of you give me a hint why got my review deleted? I didn't insult the author, didn't spam, etc. I wrote this:

Overall Score: 0 / 10
Summary: I give 0 to every impossible game
Review: There is no freakin' way to dodge the enemies blows (except the bats), and all of them hits at least 2 times before die. When I die I'm sent back to the last checkpoint, so there is no way to get past a lot of enemies. The graphics are nice so this could be fun too, but not in this form. How about making it actually beatable?!

I know the review rules, that's why I don't know what's the matter with this.

At 5/3/07 04:26 PM, kidray76 wrote: Yeah, she is right. That is an unfair review it was deleted.

*cough*HE*cough*

This flash is poor, but that's not an excuse for abuse.
Offencive Title = Offencive Reviews
Mmm, a nice bunch here.

You might say that it has unfair score but I didn't find any rule in the guideline that say I can't give low score. And anyway why would it unfair to an unfair game?

At 5/3/07 04:31 PM, Istentelen wrote: I know the review rules, that's why I don't know what's the matter with this.

It wasn't abusive. The only thing I would say is rather than state "I give a 0 to every impossible game", say something more fair like "0'd due to the extreme difficulty". Else, one could assume you give unfair low marks simply because you couldn't beat the game.

However, the review wasn't really abusive anyway :/

I'm not sure, it might be that you said you voted 0 in the summary but I don't actually know :|

At 5/3/07 04:31 PM, Istentelen wrote: Can some of you give me a hint why got my review deleted? I didn't insult the author, didn't spam, etc. I wrote this:

Overall Score: 0 / 10
Summary: I give 0 to every impossible game
Review: There is no freakin' way to dodge the enemies blows (except the bats), and all of them hits at least 2 times before die. When I die I'm sent back to the last checkpoint, so there is no way to get past a lot of enemies. The graphics are nice so this could be fun too, but not in this form. How about making it actually beatable?!

I know the review rules, that's why I don't know what's the matter with this.

Honestly, this is stuff one. There is low scores without constructive critism or advice on how to improve. Overall, it sounded more like a rant than an actual review. So I would say could possible justify deletion, but then again, could go either way.

At 5/3/07 04:42 PM, kidray76 wrote:
Honestly, this is stuff one. There is low scores without constructive critism or advice on how to improve. Overall, it sounded more like a rant than an actual review. So I would say could possible justify deletion, but then again, could go either way.

Well, maybe a rant, actually I wrote down why is it unbeatable, becouse that was my only problem with it. No advice? Ok, I didn't wrote exactly that "create a block option, dammit", but it can be read out of it. Anyway, thx for informing me.

Just one more thing: why isn't it abusive to write one single nonsense sentence with good scores? It's against the guideline, but they told me, that it can go.

At 5/3/07 05:04 PM, Istentelen wrote: Just one more thing: why isn't it abusive to write one single nonsense sentence with good scores? It's against the guideline, but they told me, that it can go.

hmm.. i'm fairly sure that it is still abusive if it says nothing about the actual submission and generally isn't helpful, despite giving a high score.

At 5/3/07 07:29 PM, NEVR wrote:
hmm.. i'm fairly sure that it is still abusive if it says nothing about the actual submission and generally isn't helpful, despite giving a high score.

Short, crappy reviews are not considered abusive if they are positive.

Flag these.

Thanks guy i got a bronze whistle you can bet im staying here for awhile and ill try to contribute more.

Some more here...

MechShadow's review.

TeenageMind

TeenageMind... again.

http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/readreview.p hp?pagea=2&pageb=-1&sort=rating&id=376711

At 5/4/07 11:31 AM, iateamexican wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/readreview.p hp?pagea=2&pageb=-1&sort=rating&id=376711

I honeslty didn't see that were abusive.

http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/readreview.p hp?pagea=14&pageb=-1&sort=rating&id=63468
Some here for everyone to fap on.

At 5/4/07 11:53 AM, kidray76 wrote:

At 5/4/07 11:31 AM, iateamexican wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/readreview.p hp?pagea=2&pageb=-1&sort=rating&id=376711

I honeslty didn't see that were abusive.

Must have been deleted before you got to it.

This has bad "you stole this" reviews spread around on the last few pages.

http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/readreview.p hp?sort=rating&id=126171&page=5

found some here, this is always a good submission to check for abuse.

Newgrounds SIM v 1.2

Check page 699 for more abusive reviews.

http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/readreview.p hp3?user_id=224396&page=1&sort=rating
Here you go.

I found a whole a bunch of abuse in my folder
An ass load here
A shit load here
boo

twistedpuppet
Some here
Yeah...
As expected
And of course.

Think you gotta be quick with this one - I might be deleted quickly

Madness....

Oh shit no.... I think it IS stolen so I flagged all of them..... Hello Garbage!

At 5/5/07 11:40 AM, Akatsuki321 wrote:

At 5/5/07 11:27 AM, thongsala wrote: Think you gotta be quick with this one - I might be deleted quickly

Madness....

Hey you sure i should flag this? if it really is stolen then i think im losing Bronze whistle....Don't do that to me man.

If it is stolen, you PM Wade - not write that it is stolen in a review...