Well, here we are with part 1 of your 2011 WWE Draft: Main draft addition. Important to note I started working on some of this before the final draft was in, so I've left sections that still work in light of the last pick, subtracted or reworked sections that don't
Let's start with the story of what this draft was: Until the end, it looked like WWE was trying to really test the idea that RAW as a brand was the draw and they would force themselves to build up new talents with Rey as de-facto top face. Then they decided to piss that away at the very end sending John Cena back over to RAW. It's still possible they're looking to build those new talents, but throwing Cena back into that mix makes me that much more skeptical.
We'll start by doing the picks in order. We're looking at whether the career of the talent drafted is positively or negatively impacted by the move, what they're potential upward mobility is on their new brand, and ultimately what they can mean to their new home.
Pick #1 John Cena from RAW to SD!: It's Cena. There's no way he doesn't go to SD! and immediately become the top baby face on the brand. So in terms of was this positive or negative? I think anything involving Cena has to be seen as immediately positive for him because there's no way this results in a down push for him.
Career Path: In the immediate future is going to be interesting, with this move WWE took a match that seemed like a fairly easy retention for Miz and genuinely throw a monkey wrench in. Does WWE now switch ol' blingey back to Cena to take to his new home? Or do they continue to have Miz retain and actually try SD! then with Christian on top? I'd like to say WWE will be smart and resist the urge to put the belt onto Cena and potentially kill the momentum Christian can receive...but I'm truly not sure.
Impact to his new home: Smackdown! just got a major face lift with this move. WWE has put the guy they've tried to build into this era's Hulk Hogan onto the Friday night brand and done as much as they could to erase the stigma that it's the "B" brand. The net may not love him, but this is hugely positive for Smackdown! and it's roster. The other interesting thing will be what does this do for the ratings for SD! and will be an interesting experiment to watch in how much Cena actually draws.
Draft Pick #2 Rey Mysterio from SD! to RAW: This was until the end something that had to be seen as a huge positive for Rey. Rey was for about an hour or so the de-facto top baby face on RAW as they got nothing else in the draft that would be an equivalent pick to say they are a level or so above Rey. This was a great move for him until Cena was drafted back. This could still be a good move for him as with Orton gone Rey becomes the number 2 face on RAW, and he's got perennial dance partner ADR
Career Path: I see Rey sliding in to feud with Del Rio again, and unlike Cena, this feels to me like a star they'll have no problem letting other guys have some clean wins over to help them be seen as legit. If RAW as a brand with a renewed focus on new stars are getting made, it seems to me that Rey whose been one of their "safety net" stars is the perfect guy to have floating near the top as a gate keeper to help those new guys get there.
Draft Pick #3 Randy Orton from RAW to SD!: This is an excellent move for Orton. Until the end of the show it looked like a wash because he was the number 2 baby face on RAW and was going to slide right in as number 2 baby face on Smackdown!. That last match changed everything for Randall Keith Orton. With Cena back on RAW Orton is now the top face on SD! replacing Edge. Even if Christian wins the title Sunday, Orton is still the biggest name on Smackdown! and with his feud with CM Punk concluding (unless we get a big shock with supplemental) there is a world of opportunity and a real clean slate on the blue brand for Orton.
Career Path: Orton is going to be floating near the top of the cards immediately. As I say he's heading to Smackdown! with no real baggage or feuds currently extant. He is a top star they can plug in anywhere right now and that offers he and WWE some very real and interesting opportunities that I hope they take full advantage of. The ideal career path would be starting him feuding with a group like The Corre, but with them getting more out of it then Nexus did. But if history teaches us anything, WWE will most likely turn Orton into the Smackdown! equivalent of Cena on RAW.
Immediate impact to the show he's on: Orton gives SD! more of a "must watch" feel among common fans as he's a guy clearly identified as a top name and people will want to follow him. He also as I pointed out earlier gives SD! one of the two top most baby faces in the company coming in free and clear of any prior feuds or baggage after Sunday. It also answers the question I think of whether or not Orton is an asset that can draw on the level of Cena for WWE.
Pick # 5 Mark Henry from RAW to SD!: This was a great move for Henry the minute it happened. Henry was doing nothing and going nowhere on RAW and a chance to change that certainly seemed to be in the offing when moved to SD! on the main show. Couple that with his beat down of his brand mates and walk off heel turn at the end of the show, and you've got a recipe for a Mark Henry run not seen since his excellent run on ECW.
Career Path: Henry is another man without a country in terms of a feud. He's a blank slate, but considering he took a shot at the now almost guaranteed World Champion it seems almost a lead pipe synch he's Christian's first feud. What really makes me wonder if how much WWE can get here as Henry has public said he's looking to be done within about a year.
Immediate impact: Henry isn't a marquee guy right now. He's probably never going to be a marquee guy, but he strikes me as an asset like King Kong Bundy. A big, credible bruiser that can be a great monster heel for some baby face challengers to overcome.
Pick #6 Syn Cara from RAW to SD!: This one looks a bit like tail between the legs. Cara has heat on him, Cara has lost any sort of mentoring influences he would have on the Smackdown! side to RAW in the draft, but it does look like WWE still wants to push him. Looks like he's headed over to SD! because that's the brand with post production to me.
Career path: Hard to say, Cara is just starting, I'm thinking a squash match or two at first, maybe he gets into a feud with Barrett or somebody as part of the IC title scene. Not sure I see any immediately logical feuds that would benefit him. He's definitely an interesting name to watch and look back at where we are a year from now.
Pick #6 Big Show from SD! to RAW: Show is Show. You know what you're getting at this point, solid mid-card attraction. His big runs are done, he's settled into perrenial tag champion partner and big guy baby face. Not much else to say.
Career path: Same as SD! the only thing that'll be of interest here is the immediate, how long do he and Kane hold the tag belts and what becomes of the team when they lose them? Right now their in a JeriShow position of tag champs from opposite brands but I don't see they're act lasting nearly as long. I'd imagine they're just waiting for the right challengers to relieve them of those titles.
Impact to show: Not much. Show is a capable mid-card attraction, but I don't think he means much at the box office at this point. I think Show may be the most drafted talent ever.
Pick #7 ADR from SD! to RAW: This was a really huge one and going to be very interesting to watch. Del Rio has been pushed to the moon but it seems he'll be denied the world title again, he's also now on a show where he's got a heel on top as champion.
Career path: Del Rio is in an interesting place. WWE has pushed him to the cusp, but with this move certainly cemented they aren't ready to pull that trigger yet. Del Rio finds himself on the same show as former antagonist Rey Mysterio and considering that all the singles champions are heels, looks like it's back to the future for Del Rio again with some capable feuding wit