You know what would be interesting? Put together a newgrounds "electoral college"; a group of 50-100 users who have been around awhile and/or voted the fairest in your guys' eyes. Let people still vote whatever the hell they want, and that will be the people's vote, just like in a presidential election. Then, let the electoral college vote, and have that as the electoral, the actual, score. I think that would probably be very democratic.
Perhaps you could even have the populus pick some of this select few (i.e. if 100 people say they want synj to be on the board, he'd be on, etc).