Hmmm if some times Tom Fulp bends the rules for certain "no animation" submissions then why are people reporting no animation submissions? is it because majority of no animation is like a repost from youtube or somewhere on social media.
Pfft hate won't hurt me
At 8/8/23 10:56 PM, SkProductions wrote:Hmmm if some times Tom Fulp bends the rules for certain "no animation" submissions then why are people reporting no animation submissions? is it because majority of no animation is like a repost from youtube or somewhere on social media.
You answered it yourself: "sometimes Tom Fulp bends the rules for certain "no animation" submissions"
I will also point to this wisdom:
At 8/8/23 08:46 PM, YendorNG wrote:To quote @Exedor:Tom's site. Tom's prerogative.
The fact of the matter is this: the only thing that makes Newgrounds any different from any other video hosting site out there is that Newgrounds focuses on animations and shuns live action content. There are animations on youtube. There are live video sites everywhere. Newgrounds' edge is its animated content. Do you want Newgrounds to remain special, or same as everyone else?
At 8/8/23 11:32 PM, Exedor wrote:At 8/8/23 10:56 PM, SkProductions wrote:Hmmm if some times Tom Fulp bends the rules for certain "no animation" submissions then why are people reporting no animation submissions? is it because majority of no animation is like a repost from youtube or somewhere on social media.You answered it yourself: "sometimes Tom Fulp bends the rules for certain "no animation" submissions"
I will also point to this wisdom:At 8/8/23 08:46 PM, YendorNG wrote:
To quote @Exedor:Tom's site. Tom's prerogative.
There's also the upcoming Live Action Jam.
The "no animation" rule is really there to filter out no-effort submissions that are better suited for youtube. Exceptions are often made for videos where it's obvious that the creator actually spent time and effort making something that's relevant to the community.
At 8/8/23 11:45 PM, guthrie wrote:There's also the upcoming Live Action Jam.
Ugh. >.<
The "no animation" rule is really there to filter out no-effort submissions that are better suited for youtube. Exceptions are often made for videos where it's obvious that the creator actually spent time and effort making something that's relevant to the community.
True; heavily altered ones, like this one.
At 8/8/23 08:53 PM, YendorNG wrote:At 8/8/23 08:48 PM, MalwareShop wrote:At 8/8/23 08:46 PM, YendorNG wrote:At 8/8/23 08:43 PM, MalwareShop wrote:At 8/8/23 08:40 PM, YendorNG wrote:At 8/8/23 08:32 PM, MalwareShop wrote:https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/894510
Is this submission against the rules of the video portal?
I think a Mod mentioned Tom gave a pass on a similar video by the same user. Likely Tom will bend the rules for this one too.
But it's jut real life footage. How is it not against the rules?
To quote @Exedor:
So uh, leave it alone?
I know it's Tom's site, but my question was not rhetorical.
I summon @tomfulp: Regarding toonhole's latest live action video, shall we effect the rules of the portal and flag it, or shall it stay per yours, and at the will of the NewGrounds' population?
It's in a grey area because we generally remove timelapse art videos but because it has a structured commentary, is entertaining and is about the creative process, it feels like it would be wrong to remove them.
The goal is to eventually allow timelapse videos alongside art pieces in the Art Portal, at which point maybe these videos would reside alongside the art pieces they are about. Until then, they've been getting a pass in the movies portal.
At 8/8/23 11:45 PM, guthrie wrote:At 8/8/23 11:32 PM, Exedor wrote:At 8/8/23 10:56 PM, SkProductions wrote:Hmmm if some times Tom Fulp bends the rules for certain "no animation" submissions then why are people reporting no animation submissions? is it because majority of no animation is like a repost from youtube or somewhere on social media.You answered it yourself: "sometimes Tom Fulp bends the rules for certain "no animation" submissions"
I will also point to this wisdom:At 8/8/23 08:46 PM, YendorNG wrote:
To quote @Exedor:Tom's site. Tom's prerogative.
There's also the upcoming Live Action Jam.
The "no animation" rule is really there to filter out no-effort submissions that are better suited for youtube. Exceptions are often made for videos where it's obvious that the creator actually spent time and effort making something that's relevant to the community.
This was useful, thanks.
At 8/9/23 07:17 AM, TomFulp wrote:At 8/8/23 08:53 PM, YendorNG wrote:At 8/8/23 08:48 PM, MalwareShop wrote:At 8/8/23 08:46 PM, YendorNG wrote:At 8/8/23 08:43 PM, MalwareShop wrote:At 8/8/23 08:40 PM, YendorNG wrote:At 8/8/23 08:32 PM, MalwareShop wrote:https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/894510
Is this submission against the rules of the video portal?
I think a Mod mentioned Tom gave a pass on a similar video by the same user. Likely Tom will bend the rules for this one too.
But it's jut real life footage. How is it not against the rules?
To quote @Exedor:
So uh, leave it alone?
I know it's Tom's site, but my question was not rhetorical.
I summon @tomfulp: Regarding toonhole's latest live action video, shall we effect the rules of the portal and flag it, or shall it stay per yours, and at the will of the NewGrounds' population?
It's in a grey area because we generally remove timelapse art videos but because it has a structured commentary, is entertaining and is about the creative process, it feels like it would be wrong to remove them.
The goal is to eventually allow timelapse videos alongside art pieces in the Art Portal, at which point maybe these videos would reside alongside the art pieces they are about. Until then, they've been getting a pass in the movies portal.
Hello Tom, I grew up on your games as a kid, I didn't think I would ever send a message to you.
Music with no animation
Reuploading blammed content under a new account
Originals:
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/rip/893545
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/rip/893810
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/rip/893960
Reuploading blammed content
Original: https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/rip/894475
Stolen
https://www.mostfungames.com/pucca-funny-love.htm
Stolen
Videos get sent to the portal when their scores are too low. But what about images? Do they just get deleted if they have low scores?
At 8/9/23 06:52 PM, MalwareShop wrote:Videos get sent to the portal when their scores are too low. But what about images? Do they just get deleted if they have low scores?
Are you referring to the art portal? If so, there's no judgment process there - the scouting system is in place instead. So, art submissions keep accumulating their votes however good or bad it is.
At 8/9/23 06:55 PM, guthrie wrote:At 8/9/23 06:52 PM, MalwareShop wrote:Videos get sent to the portal when their scores are too low. But what about images? Do they just get deleted if they have low scores?
Are you referring to the art portal? If so, there's no judgment process there - the scouting system is in place instead. So, art submissions keep accumulating their votes however good or bad it is.
So art images cannot be blammed? Tox tried explaining to me what scouting is exactly, but I don't quite get the hang of it. If I remember correctly, it's about upvoting high quality images and stuff, or something like that.
At 8/9/23 06:57 PM, MalwareShop wrote:Tox tried explaining to me what scouting is exactly, but I don't quite get the hang of it. If I remember correctly, it's about upvoting high quality images and stuff, or something like that.
You should read @Ornery's news post about scouting. It should answer all of the questions you have about the system.
At 8/9/23 07:12 PM, FilmCutterClock wrote:At 8/9/23 06:57 PM, MalwareShop wrote:At 8/9/23 06:55 PM, guthrie wrote:At 8/9/23 06:52 PM, MalwareShop wrote:Videos get sent to the portal when their scores are too low. But what about images? Do they just get deleted if they have low scores?
Are you referring to the art portal? If so, there's no judgment process there - the scouting system is in place instead. So, art submissions keep accumulating their votes however good or bad it is.
So art images cannot be blammed? Tox tried explaining to me what scouting is exactly, but I don't quite get the hang of it. If I remember correctly, it's about upvoting high quality images and stuff, or something like that.
sorry-i-buy-to-chips-want? That's what it sounds like to me when I read this.
What do you mean? Why?
no animation
no animation, copyright material, same user.
Adult Material rated as M
warning: explicit
Is ear rape allowed?
At 8/9/23 08:46 PM, Kehmicle wrote:Is ear rape allowed?
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/894638
Surprisingly (to me, at least), screamers/ear rape are not against the rules. But there's almost no chance this survives judgment, so don't worry too much about it.
At 8/9/23 07:02 PM, guthrie wrote:At 8/9/23 06:57 PM, MalwareShop wrote:Tox tried explaining to me what scouting is exactly, but I don't quite get the hang of it. If I remember correctly, it's about upvoting high quality images and stuff, or something like that.
You should read @Ornery's news post about scouting. It should answer all of the questions you have about the system.
https://ornery.newgrounds.com/news/post/388624
At 8/9/23 07:02 PM, guthrie wrote:At 8/9/23 06:57 PM, MalwareShop wrote:Tox tried explaining to me what scouting is exactly, but I don't quite get the hang of it. If I remember correctly, it's about upvoting high quality images and stuff, or something like that.
Not quite. Voting has nothing to do with scouting. Don't "upvote" or "downvote." Vote what you feel the submission deserves. The exception is when you see a red title amongst the purple Under Judgement submissions, which means it's about to be blammed. Throw a 0 its way and remove some trash from the Portal, while getting yourself a blam point earned for your effort.
You should read Ornery's news post about scouting. It should answer all of the questions you have about the system.
And if not, lemme know.
At 8/9/23 08:58 PM, MalwareShop wrote:Is this allowed on Newgrounds?
Vote 0 and find out.
At 8/9/23 09:24 PM, Exedor wrote:At 8/9/23 07:02 PM, guthrie wrote:At 8/9/23 06:57 PM, MalwareShop wrote:Tox tried explaining to me what scouting is exactly, but I don't quite get the hang of it. If I remember correctly, it's about upvoting high quality images and stuff, or something like that.
You should read @Ornery's news post about scouting. It should answer all of the questions you have about the system.
https://ornery.newgrounds.com/news/post/388624
Huh? How did you do this? This is just an empty reply.
At 8/9/23 09:35 PM, Exedor wrote:At 8/9/23 07:02 PM, guthrie wrote:Not quite. Voting has nothing to do with scouting. Don't "upvote" or "downvote." Vote what you feel the submission deserves. The exception is when you see a red title amongst the purple Under Judgement submissions, which means it's about to be blammed. Throw a 0 its way and remove some trash from the Portal, while getting yourself a blam point earned for your effort.At 8/9/23 06:57 PM, MalwareShop wrote:Tox tried explaining to me what scouting is exactly, but I don't quite get the hang of it. If I remember correctly, it's about upvoting high quality images and stuff, or something like that.
I know what titles mean, Exedor. I am a Captain.
And if not, lemme know.
You should read Ornery's news post about scouting. It should answer all of the questions you have about the system.At 8/9/23 08:58 PM, MalwareShop wrote:
Is this allowed on Newgrounds?
Vote 0 and find out.
You can vote 0 on anything, even if it doesn't break the rules. I'd rather have a whistle point, than a singular blam point, whistle points are rare and are harder to get.
At 8/9/23 09:46 PM, MalwareShop wrote:I'd rather have a whistle point, than a singular blam point, whistle points are rare and are harder to get.
You can get potentially dozens of whistle points a day if you know where to look, they just need mods/staff to action correct flags. Whistles also have incrementally more requirements every level so it seems like a challenge but its just dedication.
Blams are slow, but they've been picking up over the last few years from what it was.
Audio / Forum / Games & Movies Moderator. Flag stolen content, don't be a dingus.
At 8/9/23 09:46 PM, MalwareShop wrote:You can vote 0 on anything, even if it doesn't break the rules. I'd rather have a whistle point, than a singular blam point, whistle points are rare and are harder to get.
No, whistle points are the EASIEST to get. They're only rare and harder on the basis that there's less submissions that violate the guidelines. And even then...
Is this allowed on Newgrounds?
By the look of the submission, it's a giant NO, because nothing in the submission that you provided (From the original message.) is something that the author created. Stitching a image for one single frame and then stitching a video you didn't make into it is enough to constitute as a spam video. It has no actual animation and I doubt someone like ScriptedMatt, who only has 4 Games submissions with an average rating of 2 stars, and 2 Audio submissions with abysmal ratings, would get whistle protection.
Still image with just talking. No animation. This is just another of these A-rated spam.
This cannot be rated "E"
00:48 - There is a simulated intercourse scene.
At 8/9/23 10:04 PM, Pingu wrote:At 8/9/23 09:46 PM, MalwareShop wrote:I'd rather have a whistle point, than a singular blam point, whistle points are rare and are harder to get.
You can get potentially dozens of whistle points a day if you know where to look, they just need mods/staff to action correct flags. Whistles also have incrementally more requirements every level so it seems like a challenge but its just dedication.
Blams are slow, but they've been picking up over the last few years from what it was.
Okay, what do you think, where should I look for submissions, that violate the rules? I always look at the video portal.
Too spicy for an E rating, contains Haydee's ass slamming into a furry dude's face
Where else am I? Sheezy.Art ꟾ Geometry Dash ꟾ Reddit ꟾ BlueSky
AKA fe3l1ngsk1lled, Skilled, SkilledFeller... :3
Reuploading blammed content
Original: https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/rip/894543
Modifying someone else's work
Original: https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/189906
Speedpaint timelapse footage
At 8/10/23 07:44 AM, MalwareShop wrote:Okay, what do you think, where should I look for submissions, that violate the rules? I always look at the video portal.
Pretty sure the easiest way is just look for the Latest section in all of the portals. While you can flag Audio and Art submissions, just don't bother posting them in the board because they're more or less dealt separately from the board. Games are more harder to flag in my opinion because unlike the Movie portal, you have to actually play the game to determine whether or not the submission does or doesn't violate the guidelines. This is a barrier that's innate in its media, because for video, you can just skip sections of it just to find one thing that violates it and you're done. But a game is MUCH harder because you can't know for sure if it's in the game or not by just downloading it and then examine what's in the game. Though you could try to record the footage of the game and try to post here... But you do you.
