At 1/28/06 01:33 PM, Rslegend wrote: Here you go eaglerock, I found it.
Thanks...I saw. You seemed to handle it well enough in the NGPD. If you get enough flack for it, I'll say something about it.
At 1/28/06 02:47 PM, Dream_of_Duke wrote: I don't consider his method good either. Voting 0 or 5 simply will ruin fairness in any aspect. Let's say that a submission would be blammed with a score of 1.58. If he thinks that it is worthy to save with a 2 and vote 5 just to give the best chance to save it, then the submission would probably sneak in which it should not.
Very good example, Captain. That is the reason for my apprehension towards that voting style as well. It is not helping the Portal; it is a detriment to the sumbissions that pass or get blammed.
On the other hand, he may also blam some submissions that deserve to pass with a big fat 0. As Elite Guards, we should judge entries based on fairness and give them what they deserve instead of simply voting 0 or 5 just to increase the chance for them to be blammed or saved. Voting fairly is also the main purpose of NG, that's why we have more buttons (0 to 5) to click than 0 and 5.
Yes. They ARE there for a reason!!
On a side note, I occationally found out that the NGPD was threatened by a mod (Evark) again because he thought that NGPD looked similar with NG Army and the Blam Club.
That's not good...I hope Captain Rslegend has all in order.
It will be terrible if our brand organization gets locked. I hope that the members there can spend some time reading our posts here so that they can post some quality posts.
By brand organization, I assume you mean "branch" organization. They are NOT our branch...they are their own entity with their own leaders and their own rules. We have no affect on them whatsoever besides any alliances or respect we generate from them. It is kind of insulting to insinuate that they are nothing but a section of our Barracks.
However, thanks for your post, as I think that'll help people realize why voting just 0 and 5 is a problem. I've been trying to come up with an ironclad example as to why it is bad, and you did that for me. Thanks, sir!
*salutes*