At 4/29/05 09:42 PM, -DaughterOfHades- wrote: You've never been wrong on something? Well, I'm sorry. There, you've made a mod apoligize to you personally. Feel better?
You missed my point. It's not about "you're wrong and I'm right" or "I want you to apologize now" or anything like that - it's about feeling the need to interfere with something that works fine, is fun for those who participate in it, and doesn't bother anyone. And, what's worse, the need to interfere with it just for the sake of interfering, as opposed to interfering because there actually is a good reason.
And of course, I've been wrong on countless things in my life, and I've been critiziced for it, sometimes in a very vocal manner - and in those cases where I spouted complete nonsense, it was deserved, too. I do apologize if you felt it was too harsh (it wasn't my intention to make it seem like a personal attack), but sometimes, a verbal bitch-slap is much more effective than anything else.
Oh well.
At 4/30/05 10:50 AM, Eldarion wrote: Thanks to Tom_s00 and schneelocke :D (no <3 for you >:D)
Meanie. :)
Achievements that would NOT be acceptable to be posted in the LUL:
[...]
- Level Ups from LV 2 - 9.
I think level 9 at least should be acceptable - that's what many people seem to perceive as the end of the "noob" levels.
- Blam/Protect Rank Ups from Security Guard to Police Officer.
Police Officer should also be acceptable.
- Any posts achievement. Really, post count is a shitty stat, and one that shouldn't be held up alongside B/P, EXP, etc.
I think that's not a good rule, either. Interesting numbers should still be post-able - just like interesting numbers of blams, saves, points, XP and so on.
- Any post that relates to a level up in the future. No one cares if you need 555 EXP points to reach the next level or if you have 20 days left till Level Up. WAIT TILL YOU REACH THAT LEVEL, and then post about it.
That sounds reasonable.
Congrats stuff that would be acceptable:
- Posting specific congrats, e.g. User - EG General
Congrats stuff that wouldn't be acceptable:
- posting generic congrats, e.g. User - rank up
Where's the real difference between these things? Sure, you're not as specific when you just say "rank up" instead of naming the new rank, but that's a pretty small difference to base (un)acceptability on.
- generic 'congrats to everyone who achieved anything' posts
NOTE: If you get something like a Level Up and happen to have 1,200 blams at the same time, please just mention the Level Up. In other words, crappy achievements shouldn't be justified just because they happen at the same time as a good achievement.
What counts as crappy, though? 1200 blams are not really that noteworthy in themselves, so they probably wouldn't deserve a post of their own, but if you're already making a post, anyway, why shouldn't you be allowed to include "minor" achievements like that?
"Minor" in the sense of "interesting numbers that are not quite interesting enough to deserve a post of their own, but still somewhat interesting". I.e., 1200 would probably be a minor achievement; 1836 would not be. I personally also think that 1200 is more noteworthy than, say, 10200; when you already have 10000 points in any stat, then another 200 more isn't really much of a difference, but if you "only" have 1000, then it's a bigger accomplishment really.
Maybe I've gone into too much detail, especially on the Rank # rules, for these to be followed correctly. But then, isn't that what we need, a clear set of guidelines/rules? I dunno. Comments/Additions/Disagreements, please.
I think overall, the rules look quite OK. One thing I'm wondering about, though, is the following: why is there a need for rules at all? The topic is quite fine the way it is currently, after all, and the rules seem to be written in a way that would mean that more or less everything that's being posted now would still be allowed, too. Why establish rules if they ultimately boil down to a no-op?
Congrats to:
Myst_Williams - NG birthday
Forte_EXE - Level 10, frontpaging ^^
-Osaka- - 1500 blams, top 1000 XP users, top 1000 b/p users
YoinK_VineS - new job ^_~
Inuzuka-Kiba - top 70 b/p users
XwaynecoltX - 11000 blams
Alkador - 7.00 VP