At 9/1/24 09:45 AM, xeiavica wrote:I got some charcoal pencils, but why do you say that charcoal is a factually better tool to use?
Charcoal is generally much faster than graphite since it's softer, so you can block in forms a lot quicker, this is especially good for doing still lives/gesture drawing quickly. Also a single piece of charcoal is much darker than your standard array of pencils, so you can get really deep shadows, and by smearing/using a softer hand you can still get the lighter values in.
On top of this you have a much larger flat with charcoal sticks so you can get bigger fills in. The downside is, it is much more prone to smears/smudging and getting everywhere. to preserve permanence make sure you have a fixative spray (I just use cheap hairspray).
Also as mentioned, finished pieces in charcoal are much more readily accepted than finished pieces in pencil would be.
I'm not saying charcoal is factually better in every scenario than pencil. Sketching on the bus, or on a lunch break, pencils will take it evertime, same for doing sketches and layouts for ink drawings. But if you're doing studies in a studio environment, or want to do final compositions, charcoal is generally a superior tool (that is pencil adjacent) to learn. But pencil will also do just fine. Charcoal pencils are good to have to get in detail on full charcoal pieces or if you're working at a smaller scale, but when you're working at the larger scales that charcoal is most effective at, the extra cost and loss of variability makes them not as worth it to use.
At 9/1/24 09:59 AM, xeiavica wrote:Also, 2nd question, does anyone else here omit the blending stump entirely? For me, it smears and blurs everywhere and I find it ruins my drawing. I don't care for hyper-realistic photocopy like drawings. So I guess I can omit using one? I dunno, it's a tool but wanted to hear feedback if I was shortchanging myself not using one.
The only time I've ever used one was in classes where we were explicitly told to use them. Also sometimes for colored pencil they work, but I don't really do that type of blending much with colored pencil. It's a nice tool for if you're doing realism, or need smooth blends, but since you said you don't do that you don't really need them.