At 12/31/24 03:35 PM, DonnyGrounds wrote:my old SNES music isn't against the rules here, for me to post, but that too uses samples, they aren't really royalty-free, they are owned by companies like Roland etc. who do not allow you (in their legal guidelines) to sample their hardware (like Roland SC-55s) for use in SNES music, it has to be from the exact hardware and you must own it legally (or own a VST emu of it that is officially licensed by Roland, Korg, etc.) and I don't own either, and even then, legally-speaking I wouldn't be able to use those sounds in a sampler anyway, they have to come directly from the rompler or VST or else you are breaking their terms of use.
I would love to post my old tracks here, but I understand that those too are in a legal gray area due to the use of SNES samples, which were also ripped illicitly by the companies that made the games such as Square, who also violated Roland's TOS back in the day (which doesn't apply fully to NG's TOS, so I am not using this as an argument, I am saying this as an example that it seems that, if you look deep enough into it, every SNES soundtrack could be considered plunderphonics)
Just saying, I think Roland are kinda dicks for thinking they can own a waveform spanning less than a tenth of a second. Few if any people are going to care if you use a SNES soundfont, VST, sample, etc., unless they are purists. And rather than flag you for it being illegal, they're just going to whinge. Don't worry about that. Hardly anyone can tell the difference anyway.
So, knowing that, should every track here that uses Mario Paint samples be removed? I think I recall hearing a couple tracks that use samples from that game which is technically not, like, supposed to be legal to do.
Some more reading: https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2021/02/super-high-fidelity-mario-the-quest-to-find-original-gaming-audio-samples/
Not only would it take a million years to sort through all the songs which did have these samples, but I just find it unnecessary. The primary reason we remove things is song theft, legal danger (copyright), and well, now AI music. If the music is original and uses a Mario Paint sample, unless it's of the actual Mario Paint OST, who is really going to know?
VGM (chip and soundfont) is sort of a grey area is what I'm getting at. We would have to remove entire swathes of the genre if we were to start investigating who is really using a chip and I think it goes against our ethics tbh to try.
Happy new year
Your source for monthly music producer freebies here // ALL my big sample projects, FREE
I do professional audio critique & commissions. Catch me on YT! If you got music, I'll playlist you!