At 2/23/23 12:46 PM, Seth wrote:At 2/23/23 11:25 AM, g2961 wrote:So, you're saying that you and the other guy remixed the same song, and yours was removed for copyright. I do agree that in fairness, either the other remix should be removed or yours restored. Only exception to this would be if this other guy paid for licensing and you didn't.At 2/23/23 09:15 AM, tox wrote:At 2/23/23 07:08 AM, g2961 wrote:At 2/22/23 09:47 PM, tox wrote:At 2/22/23 04:01 PM, g2961 wrote:I don't mark this track as a track that violates the rules of the site, I just want to ask a question.
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1153434
This is a remix of "Crim3s - Lost", and I have one question. Can this be posted here? It's just that when I talked to Tom Fulp about unban, he said that it would be risky to restore my Phonk remix of this track, since it could violate copyright. My remix has no copyright, there are no vocals in it, just 4 notes that are mixed with other instruments. Can I put my phonk remix back? Also, it does not have similar synths from the original.
I listened to the track and read your question a few times, you have confused me with your question
Are you saying that your track was removed because it was similar to this track that you posted? It was inspired by that track and it sounded somewhat similar and was thusly removed? That track is Unrelated to your track and you just want our opinion?
What is the direct question that you want to ask and what are the direct issue's or problems in the equation or what kind of answer are you looking for, from us
Currently I would say that/this track is ok to be posted and remain up because it sounds unique even if it shares some similarities with other tracks that I have heard in the past
I meant that I had a remix of this original track, but it was deleted, so I decided to ask if I could get my remix back. I can send a link to my remix and you will tell me if I can get it back to my account.
Post a link to The audio so that we can listen, please do not upload it to newgrounds until you have permission to upload directly to newgrounds for this track, the 3 people are:
@pingu
@lexrodent
@tomfulp
Equally you can post your link and question/issue in:
https://www.newgrounds.com/bbs/topic/1489791
Your question will likely be handled by pingu in 1-3 days depending on schedules
However if you've already brought this to the attention of Tom, and Tom said "no" then you are likely trying to do something that can't be done with a positive outcome for yourself
Here's my remix - https://youtu.be/ZNtUg0ERB_o
Even if he has paid, he must write it on description, otherwise the remix must be deleted.
