At 5/13/06 11:38 PM, CptnJarrrrrydn wrote:
At 5/13/06 11:30 PM, The_Ghoul wrote:
At 5/13/06 08:34 PM, CptnJarrrrrydn wrote:
Cool, but Korn isn't metal. I know about your limited bm forays, but Mayhem's GDoW doesn't qualify as metal. There was a time in my life when I despised bm, but then I grew out of it. Personally, tho, I like to have reason for listening to music.
It is in my opinion. And even if it isn't, it still marks where my metal roots began. Also, I didn't just listen to Mayhem, I listened to Darkthrone, Dark Funeral, Marduk, Immortal, Emperor (still do), Zyklon (still do), Tvangeste, Dimmu, and at the moment I'm quite fond of Anorexia Nervosa, though I'm not sure if they count.
Beats me. Anywho, GDoW isn't bm for 3 reasons:
1. The production is too clean. This doesn't mean too good, just too clean; it lacks any space or grandness. The guitars sound too thrashy. The first four songs are more blackened thrash, ala Blasphemer's Aura Noir.
2. The riffs are too spikey. There's no atmosphere in the riffs, because there's too much spikes in the way the guitars are done. Black metal usually requires a steady stream of sound, not the widely varying sound found on GDoW.
3. The songs are too short. Black metal is ALL about atmosphere, and you can't achieve atmosphere with songs like A Time To Die or View From Nihil, where the main flourishes take up less than 3 minutes.
Not to say it's a bad album (I love it) but when you compare it to other bm releases, it isn't bm, it's more bm/thrash with some electronic moments.
I hate it when people who don't know enough about a genre comment on how it's all the same, the same over-used riffs, the same vocals etc, because that is a pile of shit. I could say the exact same for black metal, but I don't, because I don't know enough about the genre, and it's not the music I listen to.
Then YOU tell me: What IS goregrind? Is my assessment of it true? Is it all blasting drums, blasting guitars, and "ruh ruh ruh" vocals?
Sure, your assesment is kind of true. Well...not really. Yes there's blasts. Not all the time though. And the guitars are in no way random. And yeah, they do "ruh ruh ruh" vocals as you put it, but that's the vocal style I enjoy, so it hardly matters to me. It's more pleasing to my ears than say for instance...the forced Immortal croak. My god, seriously, if there is a vocal styling in metal that is laughable today, it would be that.
I find Goratory's vocals more distracting than Abbath's but I don't like the Frog that much either. I prefer Attila Csihar or Jon Nodtveight or Garm. Note I said BLASTING guitars, not random guitars.
Look, I don't want to argue about this, because neither of us is going to see reason.
I don't either. I was just clarifying. I've always wondered if people saw more than blasting drums, blasting guitars, and swirlie vocals. I got my question answered, so I'm gone.