At 6/3/12 02:44 PM, DeIirium wrote:
At 6/3/12 01:17 PM, ElGhoulio wrote:
At 6/3/12 07:09 AM, DeIirium wrote:
At 6/2/12 11:35 PM, ElGhoulio wrote:
At 6/2/12 07:50 PM, Tobi wrote:
At 6/2/12 06:33 PM, Sense-Offender wrote:
(
No, Bathory was black metal (and totally not norwegian.) Venom was black metal in name only. First wave black metal, which included Hellhammer/Celtic Frost, Bathory, Sodom, etc... started with Bathory and NOT Venom.
Venom's black metal came out before Bathory even existed.. They were the first to coin the term and play a style of music called black metal. Later the meaning of black metal changed, but Venom were its original creators, Venom played a style of music that no other band had played before them. Even though what people call black metal now is different from what it was back then, it can't be denied that Venom are black metal.
Venom weren't original at all. They may have invented the name, but they weren't black metal -- they were NWOBHM, which couldn't be farther from black metal. They were like motorhead with satanic lyrics, not black metal. Black metal didn't exist until Bathory -- and yes, I know Venom were first, but let's make a checklist:
Extremely raw feel -- Venom were raw, but no raw-er than other heavy metal bands at the time. Bathory, check. Venom, no.
Screeched vocals -- Venom's were barked, making them more like Savatage and Motorhead than anything extreme. Bathory, check, Venom, no.
Fast paced -- Venom were faster than average, but there were plenty of thrash bands around at the time that were faster. Bathory, check. Venom, no.
Dark atmosphere -- Venom, again, may have had satanic lyrics, but their music is about as dark as rainbows and butterflies. Again, Bathory, check. Venom, no.
Venom were the grandfathers of black metal. They carved out an evolutionary line in metal, branching off from NWOBHM, but black metal didn't come to be until the thrash influence kicked in, i.e., with Bathory.
I've been into metal for going on 12 years now and I'm also in college and am used to analytical thinking and just finished Physical Anthropology, which is about evolution. Applying that kind of thinking to metal, and Venom may have spawned black metal, but were they themselves black metal? No. Listen to Black Metal, then listen to The Return... by Bathory.
I rest my case.