At 12/18/11 07:59 PM, Idiot-Finder wrote:At 12/18/11 07:50 PM, Gobblemeister wrote:I would give Stafford a benefit of doubt despite having the same problem Eli has in the second half. As for Cam Newton, why would he be the more deserving of the pro bowl spot?
Because he is a rookie and has broken rookie and overall records this season.
Is it entirely fair? No, probably not, but regardless he deserves that spot. More than anything I think it's unfair to say Cam doesn't deserve that spot, because he does.
I hate the Giants, especially Eli Manning, so I am probably the last one to advocate his deserving anything but even I can see that there is something off about it all.
So maybe Cam doesn't have the best stats by comparison, but I think when you consider where the Panthers were a season ago and what he has done to not only make that team a threat but also make them a team people actually look at on Sunday, it's more fair than it seems.