The "Creator's" work isn't up to par.
I'm really not sure what to say. When I looked at the score, I was expecting something really well made. The animation was crude, the singing was less than amateur, and it seemed to only be made as an inside joke. I can respect that you were doing something nice for your friend, but I really don't think this deserves to be on the front page. Because you get to ultimately decide, I think you should judge more on quality, rather than things you like (or created).