Reviews for Lost Rhapsody 2

[megaman51413]

Geez...

Well, I watched it all the way through, and wow was it long. It was too redudant though. I've heard a shortened version of that song, and that may be why I got so bored with it. If you think about it, unless you do a completely different style with your animation for each verse (or maybe every other verse), it'll get boring no matter what they're doing. If it hadn't been for that, I'd say this was way up with other great movies. Ironic that some people (who obviously didn't watch it) say it was too short, when in my opinion it was too LONG. You can probably tell that I haven't seen Lost, but that doesn't change the fact that it's on here to be seen by both those who have seen it and those who haven't. If / When you do another, consider making it shorter, or at least much more varied. I didn't time it, but after I while I was just waiting for it to end, and I'll bet many other people were too. Despite that, it was still well done, especially the animation. Good luck in the future.

CapnBob responds:

That's a fair statement to make for people who aren't familiar with the show, but keep in mind that what you're attempting to do is akin to judging the length of a play when you don't speak the language that it's presented in. One of the goals I had in setting out on this was to hit almost every major plot point from an entire television season in lyrical form, and when you know what those are then you may find that there isn't really very much redundancy in the video. So if it's a choice between catering to people in the target audience and everyone else, I'm going to come down on the side of the target audience every time.

That said, I do regret not putting in more silly imagery in every section to keep non-fans entertained, but I kinda had to put a large chunk of my life on hold to get it to this level and I really couldn't afford to do that any longer. I am thinking about doing an enhanced director's cut later, but making a living and being available to friends and family again has to take precedence for now.

[LiquidSnake13]

Wow....

Hey if you want some cool stuff... he he no I kid. This vid is amazing! You've recreated all the scenes perfectly with the same touch of humor from the previous Lost Rhapsody. Hope you do one for season three.

[Shanus]

Loved it

Alot better than the first and that was amazing, animation in this was brilliant, the start was unbelievable, music was brilliant, and the humour was side splitinly good, not one fault really look forward to the 3rd

[redesigning]

Im lost, well not really

excellent job with the flash, but I know you can do better, some scenes weren't as clean as others, and the fact that you didnt use a filter for most of it is bunk IMO. Other than that you may have convinced me to go watch Lost now.

Ciao

CapnBob responds:

Cute that you think that. Go try to make something similar with a filter and get back to me.

[DanziN]

GOOODD WORK!!

MAN LOST SUCKS!!

YOUR FLASHH ROCKS!!!