Reviews for StarCraft: Alliance

[BigFurryDemon]

Uhhh

Perhaps it's just me, but the animation isn't as good as the other two. The thing I REALLY like about this, though, is that it has a very engaging storyline if you've ever played Starcraft! Keep it up; I look forward to more of your interesting creations.

But yeah, some things aren't accurate; if I had made this I would have made zealots about twice as big as marines; made BCs and carriers heck of a lot bigger, done something fancy about uncloaking (like they do in in-game cinematics), made zealots kick ass more (you know, modified speed, psi attacks, the generic stuff; make zealots have abilities other than just the normal melee shown in the game).

I really enjoy your own take on Starcraft though; if anyone says that a wraith can't kill an overlord in on hit, they're stupid. They made units have hp because the amount of shots needed to kill something includes the victim's dodging and escaping ability, I bet. I'm ranting.
I look forward to more!

LogFish responds:

Noone's actually bitched about the overlord thing yet! But I've had hitpoint bitching about other things - and yes, I think it would be bloody daft to do everything like that. So I'm not going to :)
I may have been a bit lazy animating in this one - I'm going to try and do a real good job on the next one so it might take a bit longer to come out, but it should be technically much better. Glad you're enjoying them :)

[XtimmmyX]

Awesome job.

Great job, truly a fan of starcraft's flash. Sound was a little etchy, which is pretty common. and there couldve been a nice firefight scene that the terran ouldve engaged in, but you did a great job the way you did it. Well done.

[Synthos]

mucho likings

Following your series since the first episode. Though there is still some work to your animation. It is quite high up there on the scales when lookin to other NG animations. It is not that disturbing, but some of the faces are in stark contrast to the sleek 3d models.

Storyline is interesting too making excellent use of the starcraft world, as blizzard created it.

extra bonuspoints for the gone jackals song.... made me think back of playing full throttle.... man that was a good game :)

anyways, keep up the good work, waiting for episode 4

LogFish responds:

Full Throttle rocks so much - LucasArts cancelled full throttle II as well! I suppose it's better to cancel than ruin something with a poor sequel.

[ZeroAlucard]

wooot

ive been waiting for this sweetly and patiently and i was not disapointed very nice as usually very nice indeed

-alucard

[Lord-Chapalain]

nice work mate.

i want to start off with a few improvments:

{}Try Structural damage, i can see elements but no parts blown off or anything, try that

{}try making melee combat faster. i think it's too slow.

Thats really all. you did a great job on the artwork and the dialogue is excellent, keep it up. though the clip of the beast was..alright, just not great, all on all 4/5. keep it up.

cheers mate, ChristEmortal.