Reviews for Autumn Tree

[IntriKit]

Great animation.

That was a great animation. The mood was set real well and wether or not it was mostly "ripped off" (as people seem to call it ) from the movie mentioned, that doesent matter, I concider it to be inspiration. And to the last person below....dont try to sound smart....you just look stupid, and yes, there is more to the shooting. Take a look into human nature... God.... you look so stupid trying to act smart. Great movie, great music selection, the voice acting was not as powerful and emotional as it should of been though. keep it up.

[Podnick]

What have we here?

Ho-hum
I guess it must be because I'm a limey that I'm unable to connect to the shootings on the same level as most of you guys but to me this just seems like just another piece of 'video-games-and-violent-movies-make teens-kill-people' propaganda. Humanising your villians seems to be an out moded concept to both you and your reviewers, a nation all too ready to explain events by attributing them to 'evil' people.

[notorious]

st00pid reviewers...

for those of you who think this is a ripoff of the movie 'Elephant' read the artists comments before you say stupid shit like that. They said in the artists comments that they credited the movie Elephant. Great cartoon, anyways.

[chstr-lp]

good, very good

nice graphics and a good subject to choose, and to manvsbear, this guy has made a movie about kids shooting otha kids and all u can think about is how its a rip off? i mean i agree in a way coz iv seen both columbine and elephant but come on, bad taste man, and b4 u say yer i no its in the past an all but we cant forget wot happened even for non americans its stil chilling, it happens everywhere, good flash dude,

[manvsbear]

...

From the very first scene where we are following the two boys walking towards the school with guns in their hands, it was clear that you took your ideas straight from a movie called "Elephant". From the planning scene with the map, to the blonde kid shooting the teacher and uttering "bitch", everything you did was a blatent rip off. It is way too similar, and even identical in so many aspects that it can't be denied. "Elephant" is a film by Gus Van Sant, and is based on Columbine, for anyone who wants to see it, it's a great movie.