At 11/28/08 07:09 AM, Shaun wrote:
I don't think they are hell bent on destroying him.
Have we seen the same booking? It's WCW all over again! Which is pretty easy to do since all the principles in TNA who have surrounded him are all the same guys that undercut all the young talent in WCW and kept them from getting over. Joe, Styles, and those guys are the now, they are not "the stars of tomorrow" they're the stars of now and TNA needs to get that and treat them like it. But I think they have too many egos and guys who will not accept their time is pretty well done.
Him and Styles will come out looking as strong as ever by the end of the main event mafia angle.
You have a faith in this booking team I long ago lost. I'll leave it there because obviously until it's done I can't say for a fact you're wrong. It's just my belief at this time you will be proven wrong.
That is the whole idea of it.
No, that is SUPPOSED to be the whole idea. But again, there are too many people that were involved in the height of WCW, and the angle that saved then killed it. This right now to me follows storylines like New Blood vs. Millionare's Club, or nWo vs. WCW. The point of these angles is heel group vs. face group. Heel group needs to start out strong sure, they need to Pearl Harbor (sneak attack) the faces, cheat to beat them, and just generally look like a menace at first. That's how their going to build heat and get people to be like "I hate these fucks, but they are tough and when my heroes beat them it'll be something". Then the babyfaces fight back, eventually beating the heels and destroying their alliance or running them off. That's how it's supposed to work, but it hasn't worked around this cast of characters.
New Blood vs. Millionare's was just abruptly dropped when it didn't work (that one is squarely on Russo)
nWo vs. WCW suffered from having no real ending. The heels just lost interest after beating the hell out of WCW and having most of the roster jump because they made WCW seem completely useless or uncool except for a a very small handful of guys (which really only wound up being DDP because he's the only guy I can recall that was in a featured role that didn't eventually join some faction of the nWo). That's terrible booking because they made the faces, and the home banner look utterly worthless, and that is something that Kevin Nash helped play an integral role in.
What this comes down to is with the way TNA is structured, it's like WCW. Unless the members of the Mafia are willing to lose this feud and do the things that are required to get the opponents over and finally establish the power players for TNA of the youth club and then let them do it, it's just not gonna happen. It needs to happen too because the only two ways for TNA to get into the marketplace for real is they need to present a different from WWE product, and bring along new and fresh talents that capture the imagination. Right now it's like a WCW/WWE reunion hybrid show with a lot of resources, and some new guys thrown in, but never really allowed to fully play at the big time level. I don't see that changing either.