At 8/25/17 11:08 PM, TheQuietGamer wrote:
Anyone watch Netflix's Death Note movie?
Here's a 'review' I typed up if anyone wants to skim it:
Profoundly misses what made the anime and manga compelling, but at least this has gotten people interested in the better versions again. There's a few slivers of potential here, particularly in the dynamic between Light and Mi(s)a, but it's quickly squandered. From the deaths being needlessly over the top and physically impossible, almsot every creative choice here is thoroughly misguided.
This version of Light is a spineless, uncharismatic dipshit and this version of L is a reckless, obnoxious, aggressive and impulsive imbecile who never once demonstrates any wisdom or foresight. We never get the epic '3D chess' battle of wits from the show, it's just two clueless characters bumbling around. Rather than Light being an interesting, unpredictable and morally ambiguous character he's a good-natured dumbass and Misa is pure evil edgelord to balance it, because apparently two ultra-simple characters are better than one nuanced one. For some reason every change they've made is a seemingly purposeful step toward being more generic and stereotypical.
As an example there's a pointless and poorly executed scene where Light gets bullied by an archetypal highschool jock, because surely what one of the most interesting anime characters ever created really needed was to be exactly like every other highschool movie protagonist.
Willem Dafoe's voice is a highlight but Ryuk looks horrible visually (and clearly they knew as they hide him as much as possible), they butchered his character and he's rendered entirely pointless in the story. He has no reason to be there other than because he was in the original.
What could have been interesting, since the death note itself is already such an interesting device, is to just make an entirely alternate story where it drops in the US instead of Japan and has a whole new cast of characters around it. It's an insult to everyone watching to pretend these are the same characters as the anime and manga or that they're even comparable, so why not just use new characters altogether?
The one moment it starts to feel like Death Note is the very end, and even that moment is ridiculously contrived because they've altered the notebook's rules to be overpowered and plot convenient. It feels like they started with the ending and forcefully wrote the rest of the story to build up to it, regardless of how clumsy it got in the process. In the source material Light feels like a genius when he creatively uses the book's rules and limitations to his advantage, but that doesn't work when those rules are nonsensical and so obviously created to fit the exact scenario you've come up with in advance. Exceptionally lazy writing. If this were a theatrical release it would have bombed spectacularly.
Reading back over this I may sound like a fanboy, and I am a fan of the anime for sure, but I went into this with low expectations, simply hoping the new ideas and changes could be an interesting alternative to the other adaptations. I was still left thoroughly disappointed. I don't know if anyone behind this actually understood the strengths of the source material at all.
I also found this video where L's actor is in character for an interview... it's only two minutes but god damn it's so uncomfortable.