At 7/16/10 05:01 AM, HibiscusKazeneko wrote:
At 7/15/10 11:37 PM, MattTheParanoidKat wrote:
Hibi, it sounds like you can't see the forest from the trees with your argument, you may have a few points, but this needs some cleaning up, so to speak.
This is the 21st century, anime has come a long fucking way and will only make improvements as it goes on,
True, but it still has an even longer way to go. I can accurately predict it's just going to get worse, what with the studios pushing the envelope further and further, so much that FUNimation has attempted to refuse to release uncut versions of certain series (e.g. Strike Witches and Dance in the Vampire Bund) for fear of being targeted by the FBI for obscenity.
How do you directly know it's going to get worse, per se? Of course, anime studios will push the envelope further, just like movies, games, etc., they're going to keep pushing until it becomes something like a borderline ecchi because that is what the fans want, and the studios have to get with the times and stay on par with other facets of entertainment., in terms of suggestiveness. I think the FBI has more pressing concerns than boobies and excessive blood in anime, but that's another discussion for another day.
I implore you to please stop making every fucking post that really doesn't involve what you're talking about about anime dubs. We're more than happy having you here but if you can't go without outright bitching about the state of American anime adaptations I request taking this to a livejournal.
Look, I can't stand it when people parrot the virtues of supporting the domestic anime industry and gloss over all the problems with such. Someone has to be around to set them straight.
You make it sound like the dubbing companies are jerks with nothing better to do than insult anime fans like us with shitty dubs and joke subs. Now, are they perfect?, No, but it's their job to dub the anime into English and release to a market to people who will appeal to, {e.g. a show like Bleach would appeal to a range of 13-16 yr old, whereas a show like Code Geass or Hokuto No Ken, is more suited for a 16+ audience. This isn't the 1980's, where a dubbing company could do whatever they wanted to do with a certain anime, it's 2010.
And don't give me any "just leave them alone, they have nothing to do with you" crap; this IS my business. Every dollar spent on domestically distributed anime goes toward legislation or other restrictions barring legitimate importation of anime and goods for private use. I have to warn them that whenever they buy something, people like me suffer.
Why bother buying the import version for more than $200 plus tax, when chances are you don't know what the holy hell they are talking about unless you have a decent knowledge of the Japanese language. And besides, in most box sets, if not all of them, there are options whether you want the dub version, or the original audio with subtitles. It's called marketing, maybe you should brush up on it.
Frankly you are coming across as a troll every time you stand on this soapbox about dubbed anime.
Look who's talking. You always play the Devil's Advocate and attempt to rationalize everything they do and have done over the years and encourage other users to purchase their shit just to spite me. It seems that EVERY POST you have ever made in this thread since I returned has been an attack. Why must you pick on just me?
I don't know about a troll, but more like a butthurt anime purist who is stuck with a view that all American anime dubs are fail, and the original raw version is the best thing that happened in anime history. It's time to get with the times.
It's not fucking working, and it would help if you stop talking about so we don't get into a retarded debate about this shit again because you're not going to change the opinions of the users here and I'd like to see this place as a nice place to discuss anime without the whole "Subs Vs Dubs" horseshit I get from so many otaku.
Hey, that's what we all want, to discuss anime and manga in an enlightened debate, rather than childish name calling and irrelevant talks about poop jokes and WW3 rants, metaphorically speaking.
But there are times where even fans have an archaic view about anime, and how it should be treated. As some people mentioned before, dubbing companies try their best to keep as much as the original content as much as possible along with putting it in English where everyone can understand, and keep the original version intact for people who want it in Japanese.
I may not have stated this clearly before, but I don't mind dubs as long as they're accurate and faithful to the original. Same with subs. This is not a matter of "subs vs. dubs", this is a matter of bait-and-switch prevention. If someone sold you a cheeseburger and when you bit into it you realized it was a tuna salad sandwich, you'd be pissed, right? It's the exact same thing; the distributors promise us quality anime fresh from Japan but when we look closely at it they've cut it virtually down to nothing and sold us something completely different! In any other industry, this behavior is against the law!
I don't recall that. As I stated before, the FBI has bigger things on its plate than an anime chick with boobs, or a tidal wave of blood in a fictional setting, the FCC maybe, but not the FBI.
Please, for the love of Haruhi,
Edited for reference.
Looks like I threw down the gauntlet, I like to see your response, Hibi.