At 10/3/06 03:25 PM, amplefied wrote:
If there were added points for submissions that I judged wrongly:
MISJUDGED: Have wrongly prosecuted 342 misjudged entries.
The huge problem with this is that it would force even more people to vote with the crowd, potentially.
My track record may not be perfect, but I for the most part try to vote on how I feel about a flash, not whether it'll pass or not. It's just hard when you are very sure something will pass, but you still believe it to be nothing more than spam.
I'm all for "Everything by Everyone", but surely we can agree there is a difference between a "poor" (newbie, beginner, etc) submission, a submission that you just didn't like / conflicted with personal beliefs or a submission that was genuinely spam.
How do we fairly decide? Example: I came to terms with that the Dailytoons are as much a part of NG as anything else, like them or hate them; they're definately not spam. Again with Clock and Lock movies: not everyone likes them, I don't always like them, but I don't think they're "spammy", not any more.
As for others, well I don't know. I'm just one user.