00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

honeyvonbunny just joined the crew!

We need you on the team, too.

Support Newgrounds and get tons of perks for just $2.99!

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

The Elite Guard Barracks

3,296,988 Views | 62,324 Replies
New Topic Respond to this Topic

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-07-31 17:59:53 (edited 2020-07-31 18:02:04)


At 7/31/20 03:08 PM, BlackNeko wrote:I report the obvious but sometimes I'm confused. I'll ask the experts here if its even against the rule first.

If someone creates a movie and hires a VA to voice the lines, does it break the following rule?
They do not own the images used, it's copyrighted to an artist in DeviantArt. (Also what if you got the original creator's permission?)
It's a comic, so it's basically switching panels to panels with a VA voicing the lines.

Please explain it so I can understand for future references.


I think there are a few possible combinations of the kind of submission you're asking about. Sorry if I'm not correctly interpreting your question.


  1. Someone takes another user's art and hires a voice actor to narrate. Definitely breaks the rules.
  2. Someone takes another user's comic and narration and combines them. Definitely breaks the rules, even if the creator said it was fine to submit it. Our rules are very explicit that the submitter of the content must be involved in the creation process.
  3. Someone creates their own art, submits it to DeviantArt, and hires a narrator. Doesn't break the rules.


The main thing to consider here is who is the owner of the content. Submitting it to DeviantArt doesn't transfer any kind of ownership, as far as I'm aware. But if they're taking other people's work and submitting it as their own, that is against the rules here. At the risk of being reductive, you can think of hiring a voice actor as buying the rights to that specific voice clip (in many cases, this is not the agreement between those people, but in most cases it is).


I hope that helps.

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-07-31 18:07:03


At 7/31/20 05:59 PM, GUTHRIE wrote:
At 7/31/20 03:08 PM, BlackNeko wrote:I report the obvious but sometimes I'm confused. I'll ask the experts here if its even against the rule first.

If someone creates a movie and hires a VA to voice the lines, does it break the following rule?
They do not own the images used, it's copyrighted to an artist in DeviantArt. (Also what if you got the original creator's permission?)
It's a comic, so it's basically switching panels to panels with a VA voicing the lines.

Please explain it so I can understand for future references.

I think there are a few possible combinations of the kind of submission you're asking about. Sorry if I'm not correctly interpreting your question.

The main thing to consider here is who is the owner of the content. Submitting it to DeviantArt doesn't transfer any kind of ownership, as far as I'm aware. But if they're taking other people's work and submitting it as their own, that is against the rules here. At the risk of being reductive, you can think of hiring a voice actor as buying the rights to that specific voice clip (in many cases, this is not the agreement between those people, but in most cases it is).

I hope that helps.


Thanks, that answer everything I wanted to know. I went back and read what I wrote and wow I'm surprised you even understand that.

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-07-31 18:08:32


At 7/31/20 06:07 PM, BlackNeko wrote:Thanks, that answer everything I wanted to know. I went back and read what I wrote and wow I'm surprised you even understand that.


Haha, I'm a teacher IRL and am more than used to interpreting cryptic writing. Thanks for your question and I'm glad to help out.

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-07-31 18:13:42



I'm assuming this would be breaking the rule from what I asked earlier. The comics taken from Deviantart.

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-07-31 21:52:10


At 7/31/20 06:13 PM, BlackNeko wrote:https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/761552

I'm assuming this would be breaking the rule from what I asked earlier. The comics taken from Deviantart.


That's a really good question. From my understanding of the rules, that is a rule-breaking submission. But it seems like they've been getting a pass for some reason. A mod will have to explain further because I really don't know the answer here.

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-01 23:47:56


_Barracks Roster as of August 1st, 2020:_


Hard to believe we're in August already. I started losing track of the months at the end of March, hoping against hope that some things would have improved by now - but they didn't. And it all boils down to one thing: piss poor leadership.


Many of you are from outside the U.S. (lucky buggers!) and I can pretty much guarantee that your country's leaders have been listening to REAL science, doing the best they can to contain this virus while keeping your economy afloat. They've been uniting the citizens, working together to fight this bug and work on getting back to normal as soon as possible.


Not here. (Warning: political rant about to begin. If it offends you, refer to the 1st Amendment). I was never impressed with our current leader's resume; he never should have been on the election role as he was never - and still is not - anything that resembles president material.


I don't expect a president to be perfect, or to only have policies that agree with my opinions. But what I do expect, as all US citizens should, is someone who is trustworthy, supports our constitution, and puts the people's needs first. Yes, there would be compromises, but as a good leader, they would bear the mantle of being a diplomatic unifier; they would sow peace instead of inciting division; they would be firm but fair - and, as a final measure of their humanity, they'd have a dog.


Why a dog? When I see a dog running happily to its owner/master/fur-parent, I know that they are being with treated with love and kindness. A happy dog is a strong indicator that their master is a good person. Think about it: How many cranky people have happy dogs? (actually, most cranky folks have cats, as they require less attention). When you look back in our history, the better presidents have had dogs at the White House.


Our current president is petty, childish, narcissistic, ignorant and a sociopathic liar, He has no redeeming qualities that render him capable of leading a sing-a-long, much less a country, He has failed us in so many ways, and needs to go. Those folks who voted for him in 2016 and now realize they got screwed bad, they'll vote Democrat just to stop the bleeding insanity. As for those who still think he is a good leader and worthy of your vote, I can only say this: WAKE UP! Would you want this guy working in your company, or taking care of your business, or protecting your investments? I would have fired his orange ass a long time ago.


His failure as a leader has brought us increased racial tensions, a divided country living in fear, hiding behind hyperbole and armchair opinions as he ostracizes science. 150,000 Americans dead, and that number is climbing. Yeah, eventually Covid-19 will stop - but only after countless others have died due to bad advice and poor leadership.


Biden may not be perfect, but he's pointed in the right direction. We can't take another 4 months of this, never mind another 4 years. So, to all of you non-US citizens, I apologize for our Cheeto-in-Chief's behavior, and hopefully, in a few months, we can kick him and his family out of 1600 Pennsylvania Ave once and for all.


Until then, we keep counting our dead and fight among ourselves - because that's what he wants.


</rant>


Fortunately, life here in the Barracks is much more nicer. Our band of brothers and sisters continue to fight the good fight, shoulder to shoulder, leading by example. The rewards of this good work can be seen by the promotion of @Jackho to Lt. General and @ZomALien to Brigadier General. Well done, soldiers! You deserve it! *SALUTES*


Of course, there's EGSC @Guthrie, EGSC @Peregrinus and EGSC @Exedor who continue to rock the forums, answering questions, helping out folks who bring questionable submissions to their attention, and making sure that the trash is taken out quickly. Thank you all for your dedication and service *SALUTES*


We do have a fine group of people here in the Barracks, and I can honestly say that I believe you are all good folks IRL as well. I am honored to be among you all, and I am proud to serve along side all of you. Thank you for being the "good guys" in this crazy world! *SALUTES*


Oh, and here's the roster for August 1st:


_Milestones:_

@byteslinger - 153K saves, 171K total B/P

@Exedor - 66K total B/P

@Guthrie - 57K saves, 65K total B/P

@Little-Rena - 43K saves

@Peregrinus - 30K saves

@ZJ - 13K total B/P

@ZomAlien - 18K saves, 20K total B/P


_Promotions:_

@Jackho - Lt. General

@ZomAlien - Brig. General


_The Roster:_

No. B/P / Gain / Average / Level / Change / Username / Rank / Posts / Level

01) 171,649 | 1,142 | 36.84 | B | -009.87 | @byteslinger Sup. Commander | 1 | D

02) 87,374 | 0,013 | 00.42 | D | -023.53 | @GameJunkie Sup. Commander | 0 | F

03) 67,838 | 0,002 | 00.06 | D | +000.00 | @Jolly Sup. Commander | 0 | F

04) 66,243 | 0,262 | 08.45 | C | +023.00 | @Exedor Sup. Commander | 14 | B

05) 65,591 | 1,832 | 59.10 | A | -006.05 | @Guthrie Sup. Commander | 11 | C

06) 61,901 | 0,258 | 08.32 | C | -006.18 | @Little-Rena Sup. Commander | 0 | F

07) 47,720 | 0,083 | 02.68 | D | +022.06 | @Asandir Sup. Commander | 3 | D

08) 46,246 | 0,016 | 00.52 | D | +000.00 | @Big-Boss Sup. Commander | 0 | F

09) 37,949 | 0,342 | 11.03 | C | +068.47 | @Peregrinus Sup. Commander | 0 | F

10) 37,186 | 0,116 | 03.74 | D | -030.95 | @Fro Sup. Commander | 2 | D

11) 30,419 | 0,073 | 02.35 | D | -087.99 | @Lizzardis Sup. Commander | 0 | F

12) 29,550 | 0,009 | 00.29 | D | -074.29 | @Decky Commander | 0 | F

13) 21,579 | 0,341 | 11.00 | C | +191.45 | @Jackho Lt. General | 3 | D

14) 20,145 | 0,741 | 23.90 | B | -015.41 | @ZomAlien Brig. General | 2 | D

15) 13,057 | 0,136 | 04.39 | D | +015.25 | @ZJ Lieutenant | 0 | F

16) 5,781 | 0,000 | 00.00 | F | +000.00 | @ADR3-N Sergeant | 0 | F

17) 4,213 | 0,000 | 00.00 | F | +000.00 | @dovod Corporal | 0 | F

18) 1,736 | 0,003 | 00.10 | D | +000.00 | @TheRoboTrickster Police Lieutenant | 0 | F


_Top 5 Gainers:_

@Guthrie - 1,832 (34.12% of total)

@byteslinger - 1,142 (21.27% of total)

@ZomAlien - 741 (13.80% of total)

@Peregrinus - 342 (6.37% of total)

@Jackho - 341 (6.35% of total)


Top 5 users accounted for 81.91% of B/P points (4,398 total)


_Top gainers, repeat appearances:_

@byteslinger (127)

@Big-Boss (65)

@Asandir (50)

@GameJunkie (47)

@Guthrie (38)

@Peregrinus (26)

@Jackho (25)

@Exedor (22)

@Decky (16)

@ZomAlien (14)

@Lizzardis (13)

@Jolly (13)

@Little-Rena (4)


Total gain for month: 5,369 (16 Active Members)


That's 178.97 per day, or 11.19 per day per active member.


Proud member of the EGB since 2006 |-EGB Forum-|-EGB Website-| Game and Movie Mod 2017

BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-02 10:26:59



BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-03 02:39:05



I don't believe fandubs of another user's content is allowed without explicit permission from the original creator, and something tells me they don't that permission


Original: https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/741301


Just give me the Pulitzer right now. The competition's over, close the entries, I'd like to thank everyone who lost

Epic lock

BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-04 07:25:49


Looks like someone figured out how to upload a kid's app ? Weird.


Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-04 13:45:38


Looks like I did okay for being ill, hopefully I'll do more this month!

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-06 07:33:07


Glitchy footage.


Just another NG user.

Thanks, @COOLZONE17500 for the cool signature.

BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-07 20:31:43



Even if the kid's screen capture actually worked, I'm fairly certain let's plays don't belong here


Just give me the Pulitzer right now. The competition's over, close the entries, I'd like to thank everyone who lost

Epic lock

BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-08 14:55:45


Original: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fpnp3jRxRTs

Timestamp is 2:59 - 3:07


BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-09 00:12:45



Another let's play video by the looks of it


Just give me the Pulitzer right now. The competition's over, close the entries, I'd like to thank everyone who lost

Epic lock

BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-09 03:23:46



Musicians make music , producers make products. * drops mic :D

BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-10 00:40:00



Yet another let's play video


Just give me the Pulitzer right now. The competition's over, close the entries, I'd like to thank everyone who lost

Epic lock

BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-10 17:06:08 (edited 2020-08-10 17:10:20)


Here's another stolen game - another blast of nostalgia, I can't believe it's been over a decade since this game was released!



Original:


Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-11 21:31:20



Admits he is not the original author.


I have a PhD in Troll Physics

Top Medal points user list. I am number 12

BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-12 21:05:27



-sighs- Another one


When will people learn that let's play videos don't belong here


Just give me the Pulitzer right now. The competition's over, close the entries, I'd like to thank everyone who lost

Epic lock

BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-12 22:13:47


This is like the 3rd time I've seen someone reupload this stolen game


Source: https://battlefordreamisland.fandom.com/wiki/Firey%27s_Candy_Bar_Adventure

Another Source: http://www.fastswf.com/_ij7_3c


BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-12 22:32:06 (edited 2020-08-12 22:33:13)



Just another NG user.

Thanks, @COOLZONE17500 for the cool signature.

BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-13 07:11:20


I found this = I stole this



Wrong size, Cartoon Network branding, admits in the description to finding it, doesn't seem like a parody.

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-13 10:13:14


At 8/13/20 10:07 AM, kruno5 wrote:aw s***
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/762693
Did he reuploaded that after it got deleted?
is that allowed? no. or yes?


Unless he made some visible improvements to it then I'd say it's a big no


The cake is a liar!

BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-13 15:30:41



BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-13 20:47:33



Not animation


Just give me the Pulitzer right now. The competition's over, close the entries, I'd like to thank everyone who lost

Epic lock

BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-14 00:22:33


At 8/13/20 10:48 PM, CandyBear wrote:That guy has problems, saying he respects the rules but obviously he doesn't and he submits stolen art


And pitches a fit about it every time something they post gets removed


Even if this guy somehow is above the minimum age requirement, they're clearly not mature enough to be anywhere near NG


Or the Internet for that matter

Just give me the Pulitzer right now. The competition's over, close the entries, I'd like to thank everyone who lost

Epic lock

BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-15 09:14:37


Eskimo Bob episodes that were stolen back in 2001




Wlooptidoo

BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-15 09:39:24


Footage from the Invader Zim cartoon and not an original animation

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h8zkqxWGafE


BBS Signature

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-15 10:04:15


At 8/15/20 09:39 AM, Pokemonpoeguygcn wrote:https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/762871
Footage from the Invader Zim cartoon and not an original animation
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h8zkqxWGafE


What's the matter? SCARED OF STOLEN THINGS?!

Response to The Elite Guard Barracks 2020-08-15 10:09:42


Happy Clock Day, everyone! Have fun out there and be vigilant!