At 11/9/18 12:43 PM, Decky wrote:

At 11/9/18 12:37 PM, DoctorStrongbad wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/719876
No animation at all

No, there are bits of animation in there.

Does that mean that these are okay in the future? If the author makes a series?

At 11/9/18 03:13 PM, DoctorStrongbad wrote:

At 11/9/18 12:43 PM, Decky wrote:

At 11/9/18 12:37 PM, DoctorStrongbad wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/719876
No animation at all

No, there are bits of animation in there.

Does that mean that these are okay in the future? If the author makes a series?

It's a judgement I've always taken. As long as it has some animation I let it slide.

At 11/9/18 12:43 PM, Decky wrote:

At 11/9/18 12:37 PM, DoctorStrongbad wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/719876
No animation at all

No, there are bits of animation in there.

Within the first minute. You gotta step up your game, @doctorstrongbad.

This is an edit of Hyun's Stick Figure Spotlight animations, the author admits it. I found some of the clips in

this video

, too, so you know.

I feel bad for this guy. He just wants criticism. I'll reach out to him and give him some criticism through the PMs.

• 

  by <deleted>

  Under Judgment

  (Everyone)

At 11/10/18 12:11 PM, TheReviewTrickster wrote: This is an edit of Hyun's Stick Figure Spotlight animations, the author admits it. I found some of the clips in this video, too, so you know.
I feel bad for this guy. He just wants criticism. I'll reach out to him and give him some criticism through the PMs.
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/719936

Good find, @TheReviewTrickster. I knew I recognized it from somewhere, I just couldn't pinpoint it. And thanks for using the PMs to provide feedback.

This poor kid submitted a super old online Minesweeper clone

• Unpublished Submission

Here's the original:

http://www.chezpoor.com/minesweeper/minesweeper.html

His profile says he wants to be a programmer and he has two other submissions. I don't think they're stolen, though.

• Unpublished Submission

Advertising.

• Unsuitable Submission

  This submission contains age-rated material and requires an account to view.

Wrong rating (it isn't A rated); uses "Luis Fonsi - Despacito ft. Daddy Yankee" (Label: Universal)

(in case it survives the judgement phase...I'm not putting money on that)

Edit for more:

• Unpublished Submission

Music: Crystal Pride - Thousand Nights (label: Mill Records)

At 11/10/18 07:39 PM, Peregrinus wrote: Advertising.

Thanks to whoever took the other stuff down.

• Unpublished Submission

Same user as the "advertising" one above. Another desktop capture, with a bit about how to transfer cryptocurrency at the end.

This two are not animations, just a couple of music tracks with visualizers :

• 

  by <deleted>

  Under Judgment

  (Everyone)

• 

  by <deleted>

  Under Judgment

  (Everyone)

At 11/11/18 03:06 AM, LexRodent wrote: a couple of music tracks with visualizers :

I de-visualized them. :3

• Unpublished Submission

Re submitted submission.

At 11/11/18 01:18 PM, DoctorStrongbad wrote: Re submitted submission.

I swept it away. B)

Anyone ready for a throwback to old NG?

This flash was taken from the old Assassin page

• Unpublished Submission

• Unsuitable Submission

  This submission contains age-rated material and requires an account to view.

3+ demos

At 11/15/18 03:08 AM, jonthomson wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/720124
3+ demos

Removed the excess demo.

Thanks for the report.

• Unpublished Submission

Not the original author.

• Unpublished Submission

Re submitted without change.

At 11/17/18 04:48 AM, NekoMika wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/719811
Badly copied Fruit Ninja, not sure if this warrants removal.

If he didn't credited the original author, it may be removed. Looks like that thumbnail and background is stolen.

At 11/17/18 07:08 AM, MinecraftGames wrote:

At 11/17/18 04:48 AM, NekoMika wrote: Badly copied Fruit Ninja, not sure if this warrants removal.

If he didn't credited the original author, it may be removed. Looks like that thumbnail and background is stolen.

Made the judgement.

Took it down.

Not sure what to do with this one. The art is original and it counts as a parody, but it uses Neon Genesis Evangelion opening music. I really don't wanna flag it, because I feel we can afford to let stuff with effort slide. It's transformative. Then again we could get sued. But probably not. I don't know. These cases can be tough,, but I just tend ot think parodying things like this is what makes it worthy of sparing.

• 

  NEO DS9

  by JamesBradfordHuston

  Neon Genesis Evangelion crossover w/ Star Trek Deep Space Nine

  Movie

  1,194 Views

  (Everyone)

At 11/17/18 11:48 AM, TheReviewTrickster wrote: Then again we could get sued. But probably not. I don't know. These cases can be tough,, but I just tend ot think parodying things like this is what makes it worthy of sparing.

So the label for that doesn’t actively enforce the copyright for it. They have DMCA’d media now and again if someone is clearly trying to make a buck on an unchanged upload of the song, but in general Japanese media companie are more lax for copyright enforcement as the interpretation of “fair use” is more broad than in the US.

One reason for lower enforcement is that it “grows the brand” through fan art/ media reference/ memes (which Cruel Angels Thesis has hit meme status) as it helps continue merchandise sales for completed series like NGE.

The label (Starchild) doesn’t appear to seek lawsuit normally, just a polite ask for removal or failing that a DMCA to pull media which is just a content rip (full episodes, full track uploads with no added content). The song has also been sampled and covered a bunch of times, which is something to consider.

(Not saying let it slide, not my call, just a perspective on enforcement if anyone is interested)

At 11/17/18 12:49 PM, Peregrinus wrote:
(Not saying let it slide, not my call, just a perspective on enforcement if anyone is interested)

That means there is no copyright violation according to the original author(s). Alright in my book then.

At 11/17/18 12:56 PM, TheReviewTrickster wrote:

At 11/17/18 12:49 PM, Peregrinus wrote:
(Not saying let it slide, not my call, just a perspective on enforcement if anyone is interested)

That means there is no copyright violation according to the original author(s). Alright in my book then.

Well, there is legally an infringement of copyright. I should clarify there.

But as far as enforcement, they generally gave a “meh” attitude. Think how Sega encourages people to use it’s properties to keep the brand alive, they still hold the copyright.

Neon Genesis Evsngleion is also the greatest story ever told in any medium. Just fyi.

• 

  by <deleted>

  Under Judgment

  (Everyone)

No animation.

At 11/18/18 12:57 PM, DoctorStrongbad wrote: No animation.

Taken down.

• 

  by <deleted>

  Under Judgment

  (Everyone)

Game play footage

At 11/18/18 05:41 PM, DoctorStrongbad wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/720305
Game play footage

Removed.

This is an ad

• 

  by <deleted>

  Under Judgment

  (Everyone)

Another two of this.

Not animated, just audio and visualizers :

• Unpublished Submission

• Unpublished Submission

Same guy as the previous 2. I don't get why he's not using the audio portal instead.