00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

Manvineo just joined the crew!

We need you on the team, too.

Support Newgrounds and get tons of perks for just $2.99!

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

Best of August 2024!

24,403 Views | 59 Replies
Respond to this Topic

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-14 23:21:44 (edited 2024-09-14 23:24:13)


These results kind of make me think that the people that were voting only viewed the top half of the pool, because all of the good videos were on the bottom, and there were some f'ing masterpieces down there... Not trying to dump on anyone's parade, but I feel like the others who voted, kind of took a half-ass approach, I spend hours reviewing every single video, piece of art, and audio, and I recognize most of these were in the top 25 submissions on the list, meaning they didn't even get halfway down the list.


Again I'm not trying to dump on anyone's parade or say that they shouldn't be winners, I just feel like there should be a little bit more Integrity in the voting process, if not for the creators, at least for your own sense of pride

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-14 23:37:36


This was my very first time voting (I listened/watched/played all the submissions) and it's insane that some of the best works didn't even get to top 5 wth 😭 , congrats to the winners though πŸ’€


QBD

BBS Signature

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-15 03:31:53


Thanks for the mention! Congrats to @Dieswyx for 3rd place for music!! πŸ’œ


And Congrats to the rest of the Winners!! Great Month! πŸ’–


BBS Signature

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-15 03:51:47


God damn August was packed. Not just with excellent work, but with excellent updates.

Congrats, everyone!

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-15 04:44:20


Thank you for top 5 art!!!


Was kinda hoping for the Autumn piece to show up on the voting but something is better than nothing haha

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-15 07:40:23


At 9/14/24 11:21 PM, fullmetall wrote:These results kind of make me think that the people that were voting only viewed the top half of the pool, because all of the good videos were on the bottom, and there were some f'ing masterpieces down there... Not trying to dump on anyone's parade, but I feel like the others who voted, kind of took a half-ass approach, I spend hours reviewing every single video, piece of art, and audio, and I recognize most of these were in the top 25 submissions on the list, meaning they didn't even get halfway down the list.

Again I'm not trying to dump on anyone's parade or say that they shouldn't be winners, I just feel like there should be a little bit more Integrity in the voting process, if not for the creators, at least for your own sense of pride


https://www.newgrounds.com/bbs/topic/1537550#bbspost27932838_post_text

Doesn't each voter get an individual, randomized list to vote on? Or does each voter get the same randomized list? I did really try to put a lot of dedication into selecting the most suited audio tracks, and 4/5 of the tracks I selected ended up as top 5. I don't think it's by chance they were given the ranking they were.


HeroPapaya~

BBS Signature

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-15 07:43:55


At 9/14/24 11:21 PM, fullmetall wrote:These results kind of make me think that the people that were voting only viewed the top half of the pool, because all of the good videos were on the bottom, and there were some f'ing masterpieces down there... Not trying to dump on anyone's parade, but I feel like the others who voted, kind of took a half-ass approach, I spend hours reviewing every single video, piece of art, and audio, and I recognize most of these were in the top 25 submissions on the list, meaning they didn't even get halfway down the list.

Again I'm not trying to dump on anyone's parade or say that they shouldn't be winners, I just feel like there should be a little bit more Integrity in the voting process, if not for the creators, at least for your own sense of pride


The list of nominees should be randomized for each user, although it will move things to the top if you favorited or voted highly on them. It would be ideal that people explore everything thoroughlyΒ though!


Working on Nightmare Cops!

BBS Signature

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-15 09:51:34


At 9/14/24 11:21 PM, fullmetall wrote:These results kind of make me think that the people that were voting only viewed the top half of the pool, because all of the good videos were on the bottom, and there were some f'ing masterpieces down there... Not trying to dump on anyone's parade, but I feel like the others who voted, kind of took a half-ass approach, I spend hours reviewing every single video, piece of art, and audio, and I recognize most of these were in the top 25 submissions on the list, meaning they didn't even get halfway down the list.

Again I'm not trying to dump on anyone's parade or say that they shouldn't be winners, I just feel like there should be a little bit more Integrity in the voting process, if not for the creators, at least for your own sense of pride


I've been saying this for years. The judges should be picked based on who has already viewed the most nominees. I get picked to vote every month despite not having viewed any of them.

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-15 14:06:42 (edited 2024-09-15 14:08:20)


This was an incredible month for games, including two 5+ hour adventure masterpieces:




Just like FutureCopLGF, these two topped my list as well, but even though I'm a huge Ferociter fan Mars Underground was good enough to take the #1 spot for me. The fact that I spent the hours I needed to finish the whole thing before voting may have made the difference.


I'm often put off by the BOTM results, but I don't think I've ever been this flabbergasted before. I simply do not understand how Ferociter's game did not even make the top 30. But that's not the only great game that didn't make the top 30. I voted for these two absolute gems as well:




And I don't think I voted for this one, but it probably deserves to be on the top 30 because of its cool crafting mechanic:



I don't like raining on the winner's parade, but I really feel like we didn't need another Vampire Survivors clone at the top.


Anyway, I also want to talk about how this is the first month with the new voting system. There are a lot of quality-of-life upgrades, like saving your progress and getting to still click on the links after you pick them. I kind of miss seeing the icons on a grid, but that's only important because it helps me count. The only major complaint I have is starting the voting a week later, because I liked being able to get a head start on checking out the nominees by clicking on front page submissions and being reasonably confident about what month they were submitted in. Maybe I'll get used to it.


A major change for me is getting to vote on ten games AND ten movies instead of having to split it. I certainly felt that this month, since there were so many games I wanted to vote for.


At 9/14/24 12:23 PM, KubaAdrianowicz wrote:No matter how much exp to vote I collect and no matter how I purposely inflate the smaller animations purposely leaving out Nox's animations well he will always be in first place!


I try to vote for underdogs because I know a handful of legendary animators are shoo-ins so there's no need for me to vote for them, but I have nothing against these legendary animators.

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-15 14:17:32


At 9/15/24 02:06 PM, TharosTheDragon wrote:This was an incredible month for games, including two 5+ hour adventure masterpieces:

https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/944751

https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/944659

Just like FutureCopLGF, these two topped my list as well, but even though I'm a huge Ferociter fan Mars Underground was good enough to take the #1 spot for me. The fact that I spent the hours I needed to finish the whole thing before voting may have made the difference.

I'm often put off by the BOTM results, but I don't think I've ever been this flabbergasted before. I simply do not understand how Ferociter's game did not even make the top 30. But that's not the only great game that didn't make the top 30. I voted for these two absolute gems as well:

https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/945825

https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/945248

And I don't think I voted for this one, but it probably deserves to be on the top 30 because of its cool crafting mechanic:

https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/945531

I don't like raining on the winner's parade, but I really feel like we didn't need another Vampire Survivors clone at the top.

Anyway, I also want to talk about how this is the first month with the new voting system. There are a lot of quality-of-life upgrades, like saving your progress and getting to still click on the links after you pick them. I kind of miss seeing the icons on a grid, but that's only important because it helps me count. The only major complaint I have is starting the voting a week later, because I liked being able to get a head start on checking out the nominees by clicking on front page submissions and being reasonably confident about what month they were submitted in. Maybe I'll get used to it.

A major change for me is getting to vote on ten games AND ten movies instead of having to split it. I certainly felt that this month, since there were so many games I wanted to vote for.
At 9/14/24 12:23 PM, KubaAdrianowicz wrote:No matter how much exp to vote I collect and no matter how I purposely inflate the smaller animations purposely leaving out Nox's animations well he will always be in first place!


I try to vote for underdogs because I know a handful of legendary animators are shoo-ins so there's no need for me to vote for them, but I have nothing against these legendary animators.


I agree with your opinion and I use such practices myself. I admit that I got carried away a bit, I have nothing against Nox and his developing universe of conspiracy, it frustrates me that his animations take the first place, making it difficult for new faces to shine on this site

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-15 17:12:13


At 9/14/24 11:21 PM, fullmetall wrote:These results kind of make me think that the people that were voting only viewed the top half of the pool, because all of the good videos were on the bottom, and there were some f'ing masterpieces down there... Not trying to dump on anyone's parade, but I feel like the others who voted, kind of took a half-ass approach, I spend hours reviewing every single video, piece of art, and audio, and I recognize most of these were in the top 25 submissions on the list, meaning they didn't even get halfway down the list.

Again I'm not trying to dump on anyone's parade or say that they shouldn't be winners, I just feel like there should be a little bit more Integrity in the voting process, if not for the creators, at least for your own sense of pride


I guess some people might even be just voting for their friends submissions, but you can't really prevent those kinds of things from happening if you want the community to be involved. Other than cherry picking a select few judges who will always thoroughly review each nominated submission before casting their votes there's not much of a way to fix it.


Not to mention that art can be very subjective. Still, I'm personally just glad that the first monthly audio winner wasn't some effortless dubstep shitpost.

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-15 21:08:24


yay


lol

BBS Signature

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-16 00:04:49


i like the new voting system. congrats to the winners

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-16 03:08:44


Holy hell! Some amazing stuff all around here, congratulations to the talented winners and massive thank you to James Lee for the very generous donation!!

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-16 05:22:56


Been a hot minute since I saw one of my games here. Lots of awesome stuff up there. <3

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-16 07:43:44


At 9/14/24 11:47 AM, TomFulp wrote:This month marked the debut of our new Monthly Voting System, introducing categories for Best Art and Best Music. Your votes are in and the best of August have been determined!

πŸ† Top Five Movies ($100 each + $200 for best Original)

https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/942714
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/944313
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/943861
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/944359
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/942507

The top movie based on original material and winner of $300 total is Metrogeneric. Congrats @Ennuikal!

πŸŽ‰ BIG NEWS - @JamesLee has donated $200 that he would like to go to @CybeR and @ToadBurgerTV, the phenomenal 6th and 7th runner-ups!

https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/944245
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/945739

πŸ† Top Five Games ($100 each + $200 for best Original)

https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/945859
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/945878
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/945073
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/941943
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/945126

The top game based on original material and winner of $300 total is Dungeon Watchers. Congrats @rm120!

@FuturecopLGF made a Best Games of August post, including a video where he plays every featured game and gives feedback. His #1 pick this month was Pent's Wacky, Zany Road Trip to Adulthood, which will be receiving a $60 bonus prize. It ranked #35 overall but deserves more eyeballs and accolades!

Thank you @PuffballsUnited and @TeamTrivial for sponsoring our game prizes this month!

πŸ† Top Five Music ($100 for First Place)

https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1350221
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1348143
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1354322
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1347083
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1346680

πŸŽ‰ BIG NEWS - Starting next month, @RobTop with Geometry Dash has come aboard as a $500 monthly music sponsor! This means the top five songs from September will receive $100 each, with a $100 bonus for the top original song.

πŸŽ‰ First place winner @ZaneLittle is also paying it forward by donating his prize money, so we'll award $50 each to the 6th and 7th best music of September!

πŸ† Top Five Art ($100 for First Place, $50 each for 2nd-5th)

https://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/deimosart/no-gods-no-masters
https://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/mitsutan/brazilian-hatsune-miku
https://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/bacun/risky
https://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/natthelich/ghost-mommy
https://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/degodraws/dbcollab2024-wallart

Thank you @wheezl, @53xy83457, @StrangInk and @River for sponsoring our art prizes this month!

πŸŽ‰@NatTheLich is donating their prize back, so it will go towards art prizes next month!

If you’d like to help keep these prizes going, please consider becoming a Supporter!

We’re also looking for big spenders who are down to commit $50 or more per month to be category sponsors. If you set up a subscription for $50+ per month, let me know what category you would like to sponsor. If you commit $100 or more, you can also promote a link in these posts, in addition to your name!

Runner-Up Movies

8. Bell Ringer πŸ””
9. Sol Badguy STUBS his toe
10. Dragon ball collab Trailer
11. i don't have a good poker face
12. Yume Nikki Cook Eggplant Parmesan
13. SECOND RATE SERVICE
14. How It Feels To Play Sonic Unleashed
15. 64 Bits - SΜΆmΜΆoΜΆoΜΆtΜΆh FailWare (A WarioWare Parody!)
16. The Curse of Dracular
17. Mario Down Special
18. Port by the Sea Pilot
19. Operation Egg Drop
20. THE CLONE HIGH ENDING WE DESERVE
21. Storm ⚑
22. FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY’S COLLAB
23. Vi the Imp in "Whisking the Warzone"
24. Soda Street
25. Summer Times-Newgrounds anime shorts-[VHS]-{sub}
26. Erm What the Sigma (EPIC REMIX!!!)
27. Cheating Death
28. THE ULTIMATE HENCHMAN
29. The King Wonders
30. Costco Fahrenheit: Hostage crisis

Runner-Up Games

6. Clocks of the BBS 2024
7. SUPER FREAKING WEIRD FREAKING BOWLING
8. Lee's DeLeeVery Service!
9. Bastard Aliens
10. RPG MK. II
11. A City Capture
12. Human Hunters
13. Deep Snake
14. OUTSIDE
15. Goblins Revolt
16. Striving Perfection: Scalable Dreams
17. UNWORTHY
18. scaling a mountain using the second amendment
19. DEAD DETENTION #2 (Rescribbled)
20. BABEL
21. Scarab's Ring
22. Topeka Drift
23. Mars Underground (full game)
24. Cannibal Holocaust - The LCD Game
25. Go Figure
26. Probably Art
27. Lightning Katana [Demo]
28. Beetle Battle
29. Off the Grid - Summer 2024 Collab
30. ZAH'S REVENGE 3

Keep reading below for Art and Audio runner-ups, as well as more events from August!


the winners have done a great job

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-16 10:01:43


HELL YEAH!! congrats to the winners!!


carrd (i dont take commissions...yet)


i'm probably playing persona 3 reload

BBS Signature

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-16 10:38:57


At 9/14/24 12:23 PM, KubaAdrianowicz wrote:
At 9/14/24 11:47 AM, TomFulp wrote:This month marked the debut of our new Monthly Voting System, introducing categories for Best Art and Best Music. Your votes are in and the best of August have been determined!

Top Five Movies ($100 each + $200 for best Original)

https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/942714
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/944313
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/943861
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/944359
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/942507

The top movie based on original material and winner of $300 total is Metrogeneric. Congrats @Ennuikal!

Top Five Games ($100 each + $200 for best Original)

https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/945859
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/945878
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/945073
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/941943
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/945126

The top game based on original material and winner of $300 total is Dungeon Watchers. Congrats @rm120!

@FuturecopLGF made a Best Games of August post, including a video where he plays every featured game and gives feedback. His #1 pick this month was Pent's Wacky, Zany Road Trip to Adulthood, which will be receiving a $60 bonus prize. It ranked #35 overall but deserves more eyeballs and accolades!

Thank you @PuffballsUnited and @TeamTrivial for sponsoring our game prizes this month!

Top Five Music ($100 for First Place)

https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1350221
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1348143
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1354322
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1347083
https://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1346680

Top Five Art ($100 for First Place, $50 each for 2nd-5th)

https://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/deimosart/no-gods-no-masters
https://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/mitsutan/brazilian-hatsune-miku
https://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/bacun/risky
https://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/natthelich/ghost-mommy
https://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/degodraws/dbcollab2024-wallart

Thank you @wheezl, @53xy83457, @StrangInk and @River for sponsoring our art prizes this month!

If you’d like to help keep these prizes going, please consider becoming a Supporter!

We’re also looking for big spenders who are down to commit $50 or more per month to be category sponsors. If you set up a subscription for $50+ per month, let me know what category you would like to sponsor. If you commit $100 or more, you can also promote a link in these posts, in addition to your name!

Runner-Up Movies

6. IMPRESS YOUR CREATORS
7. Pepe's day off
8. Bell Ringer πŸ””
9. Sol Badguy STUBS his toe
10. Dragon ball collab Trailer
11. i don't have a good poker face
12. Yume Nikki Cook Eggplant Parmesan
13. SECOND RATE SERVICE
14. How It Feels To Play Sonic Unleashed
15. 64 Bits - SΜΆmΜΆoΜΆoΜΆtΜΆh FailWare (A WarioWare Parody!)
16. The Curse of Dracular
17. Mario Down Special
18. Port by the Sea Pilot
19. Operation Egg Drop
20. THE CLONE HIGH ENDING WE DESERVE
21. Storm ⚑
22. FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY’S COLLAB
23. Vi the Imp in "Whisking the Warzone"
24. Soda Street
25. Summer Times-Newgrounds anime shorts-[VHS]-{sub}
26. Erm What the Sigma (EPIC REMIX!!!)
27. Cheating Death
28. THE ULTIMATE HENCHMAN
29. The King Wonders
30. Costco Fahrenheit: Hostage crisis

Runner-Up Games

6. Clocks of the BBS 2024
7. SUPER FREAKING WEIRD FREAKING BOWLING
8. Lee's DeLeeVery Service!
9. Bastard Aliens
10. RPG MK. II
11. A City Capture
12. Human Hunters
13. Deep Snake
14. OUTSIDE
15. Goblins Revolt
16. Striving Perfection: Scalable Dreams
17. UNWORTHY
18. scaling a mountain using the second amendment
19. DEAD DETENTION #2 (Rescribbled)
20. BABEL
21. Scarab's Ring
22. Topeka Drift
23. Mars Underground (full game)
24. Cannibal Holocaust - The LCD Game
25. Go Figure
26. Probably Art
27. Lightning Katana [Demo]
28. Beetle Battle
29. Off the Grid - Summer 2024 Collab
30. ZAH'S REVENGE 3

Keep reading below for Art and Audio runner-ups, as well as more events from August!

Holy crap! Why is it that every time the Nox animation comes up he always has to, but it has to come first? Every time! No matter how much exp to vote I collect and no matter how I purposely inflate the smaller animations purposely leaving out Nox's animations well he will always be in first place! Sorry I got so carried away, I had to shout it out. I'm glad that at least Metrogeneric is in second place and Bunny3 in third place, because in my opinion @Ennuikal and @Jaquin deserve such a high place, and to @JamesLee give a little foray to others, I know that you try to put as much work as possible in your videos but give some chance to others, on this site there are many artists as deserving of attention. Please don't cancel me.


Well, this age pretty bad. Honestly didn't expect such a nice gesture from James, it's nice that the bigger developers are arguing against the smaller ones.Β Β I apologize to everyone that I acted like a complete Jackass, I will not post anymore.

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-16 11:15:17


I really loved the new monthly voting system. FINALLY THE MONTHLY VOTING PAGE BEEN UPDATED. It looks so much better with the voting of art and music. I rarely listen to music on NG, so this was cool. And it’s even easy to find the movies and games you watched and favorite.

Everyone did an amazing job.


Now we just need to make more stuff for the Download page.


I like Pizza!

BBS Signature

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-16 11:30:24 (edited 2024-09-16 11:31:57)


I really like most of these picks. Especially the animation made by Ennuikal. I can't wait to watch more and possibly vote for it next time.

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-18 23:39:45


At 9/15/24 09:51 AM, TharosTheDragon wrote:
At 9/14/24 11:21 PM, fullmetall wrote:These results kind of make me think that the people that were voting only viewed the top half of the pool, because all of the good videos were on the bottom, and there were some f'ing masterpieces down there... Not trying to dump on anyone's parade, but I feel like the others who voted, kind of took a half-ass approach, I spend hours reviewing every single video, piece of art, and audio, and I recognize most of these were in the top 25 submissions on the list, meaning they didn't even get halfway down the list.

Again I'm not trying to dump on anyone's parade or say that they shouldn't be winners, I just feel like there should be a little bit more Integrity in the voting process, if not for the creators, at least for your own sense of pride

I've been saying this for years. The judges should be picked based on who has already viewed the most nominees. I get picked to vote every month despite not having viewed any of them.


My wife's acc was also selected to be a random judge, and the order of the submissions were only shuffled 1-4 slots away from what they showed on my list, like entry #1 on my list would be #4 on her list and entry #25 would be like entry #22 on her list... It could hardly be considered shuffled, just slightly shifted a few slots at most... I know the selection for judges is completely random, because I've had my account since 2006 and I've only been selected twice to be a random judge, whereas my wife only made her account a few years ago and this is like her 5th time

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-19 08:37:46


At 9/18/24 11:39 PM, fullmetall wrote:I know the selection for judges is completely random, because I've had my account since 2006 and I've only been selected twice to be a random judge, whereas my wife only made her account a few years ago and this is like her 5th time


It's certainly not random. My understanding is that it picks the top 2000 users who were active during the month. This is consistent with what I've observed. Since I'm in the top 2000 users overall, I get picked to be a judge any time I'm active. If I don't interact with the site, I don't get picked.

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-20 03:19:26


I forgot to mention that I also voted for this one which didn't make the top 30:


Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-20 19:12:51


Belated Congrats! to the winners, as well as to the runner-ups!


Are you an artist? Do you need help?

╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╗

β•‘ Guides, Tutorials & Other Help: Self-Publishing β•‘ General Art Creation β•‘ Game Development β•‘ Audio Production β•‘

β•šβ•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•β•

Would you like to help me? If you come across a good tutorial, send it my way and I'll try to squeeze it in.


Would you hate to see Newgrounds shut down forever? Can you spare 3 bucks?

Click here to keep the servers running. (Click here for a full list of perks.)


My Frequently Given Replies.

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-21 10:35:59


well deserved for Metrogenetics to be in the best of August and in the thumbnail, here's a fanart (made an year ago) to celebrate

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-22 18:06:52


Congrats to the all of the winners of August 2024. It's nice to include Music and Art for the first (for monthly voting). I had no problem vote on the 40 submissions, as opposed to voting for any of the 10 movies or games. I might try this again for mobile, in the next week or so.


SM/AMA/FAQs (Now both are ready, well sort of) My shortcuts

BBS Signature

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-09-30 13:08:35


At 9/19/24 08:37 AM, TharosTheDragon wrote:
At 9/18/24 11:39 PM, fullmetall wrote:I know the selection for judges is completely random, because I've had my account since 2006 and I've only been selected twice to be a random judge, whereas my wife only made her account a few years ago and this is like her 5th time

It's certainly not random. My understanding is that it picks the top 2000 users who were active during the month. This is consistent with what I've observed. Since I'm in the top 2000 users overall, I get picked to be a judge any time I'm active. If I don't interact with the site, I don't get picked.


My wife maybe gets on once every other month, does not comment, does not rate, looks at a few fan art pictures or watches a video, then hops off and forgets about it for a month or so, because she's a squirrel, I on the other hand am on several times a month, usually rating or reviewing something at least once a month, and I've been selected twice in nearly 20 years, she's been selected 5 times in 2 years, your theory doesn't match up with what i've experienced

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-10-01 01:39:47


At 9/30/24 01:08 PM, fullmetall wrote:
At 9/19/24 08:37 AM, TharosTheDragon wrote:
At 9/18/24 11:39 PM, fullmetall wrote:I know the selection for judges is completely random, because I've had my account since 2006 and I've only been selected twice to be a random judge, whereas my wife only made her account a few years ago and this is like her 5th time

It's certainly not random. My understanding is that it picks the top 2000 users who were active during the month. This is consistent with what I've observed. Since I'm in the top 2000 users overall, I get picked to be a judge any time I'm active. If I don't interact with the site, I don't get picked.

My wife maybe gets on once every other month, does not comment, does not rate, looks at a few fan art pictures or watches a video, then hops off and forgets about it for a month or so, because she's a squirrel, I on the other hand am on several times a month, usually rating or reviewing something at least once a month, and I've been selected twice in nearly 20 years, she's been selected 5 times in 2 years, your theory doesn't match up with what i've experienced


Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-10-06 06:46:39


At 9/30/24 01:08 PM, fullmetall wrote:My wife maybe gets on once every other month, does not comment, does not rate, looks at a few fan art pictures or watches a video, then hops off and forgets about it for a month or so, because she's a squirrel, I on the other hand am on several times a month, usually rating or reviewing something at least once a month, and I've been selected twice in nearly 20 years, she's been selected 5 times in 2 years, your theory doesn't match up with what i've experienced


It sounds like you still think my theory has something to do with how active a user is, and that's not what I'm saying. The top users are determined by experience points, which could've been accumulated a long time ago, so you could rank very highly even if you're not doing diddly these days.


If you're not on the top 2000 users overall, then you could've been selected in the past for two reasons:

  1. You used to be in the top 2000 users overall during the months you were selected.
  2. During the months you were selected, enough of the overall top 2000 were inactive to bump you up to the top 2000 active users. For example, if you're in 2500th place and 500 of the top 2000 weren't active then you'd be selected.


As for your wife, it sounds like she's one of the top 2000 users overall, which means she'd get selected any month she's active. The system counts you as active even if you visit for just one day during the month.

Response to Best of August 2024! 2024-10-07 17:30:35


At 10/6/24 06:46 AM, TharosTheDragon wrote:It sounds like you still think my theory has something to do with how active a user is, and that's not what I'm saying. The top users are determined by experience points, which could've been accumulated a long time ago, so you could rank very highly even if you're not doing diddly these days.

If you're not on the top 2000 users overall, then you could've been selected in the past for two reasons:

As for your wife, it sounds like she's one of the top 2000 users overall, which means she'd get selected any month she's active. The system counts you as active even if you visit for just one day during the month.


My wife is literally level 2, she's never been in the top 100,000 let alone the top 2,000