At 12/30/24 06:04 PM, Jackho wrote:At 12/30/24 05:26 PM, Pingu wrote:The Book Club has garnered a whole two pages of posts since 2016, a bunch of which were just statements that the user is reading X with no follow up on completion or review. I liked how the reading challenges provided little capsules for tracking goals and kept more of a core bunch of users. The trouble with long standing clubs are the dozens of pages of stale content to either sift through or try to not repeat.
Fair point, although these threads have taken the need for that one since 2016 also. I think a few spill-over users from here to there could rekindle it. But then you'd have newcomers looking at the original posts and not knowing what the thread has turned into, so maybe a new, perpetual and self-guided "Yearly Reading Challenge" thread would be a better substitute.
I happen to like the annual thread - It's neat to search back to previous threads and see where everyone started and ended up. In a club thread the start of year and end of year reports will get buried in random page numbers that might change if active posters delete their accounts at some point in the future.
@Jackho I wanna give you props for running these threads for so many years. They got me reading again for fun after a really long time. I've read new authors and series based on recommendations from other participants as well. I hope someone will take the reins and continue the tradition.