00:00
-:-
--:-- / --:--
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

Imm-o just joined the crew!

We need you on the team, too.

Support Newgrounds and get tons of perks for just $2.99!

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

Review Request Club

849,050 Views | 8,782 Replies
New Topic Respond to this Topic

Response to Review Request Club Apr 27, 2011


At 4/25/11 08:03 PM, sixflab wrote: I miss the days where each request would get 5+ reviews.

I do too.

I remember requesting for some of my shittiest works ever, and really insightful reviewers like Haggard and Coop took those requests. It's kind of annoying how now that I actually need the reviews, those prolific reviewers have left the club. Now, I'm not complaining at all, but usually only one person takes up my requests, and I don't get a wide enough dissection of my pieces. I'm sure I'm not alone on that either.

Ah well, I suppose I should just be thankful that I'm even getting reviews in the first place.

Response to Review Request Club Apr 27, 2011


At 4/27/11 10:12 AM, Sawdust wrote:
I remember requesting for some of my shittiest works ever, and really insightful reviewers like Haggard and Coop took those requests. It's kind of annoying how now that I actually need the reviews, those prolific reviewers have left the club. Now, I'm not complaining at all, but usually only one person takes up my requests, and I don't get a wide enough dissection of my pieces. I'm sure I'm not alone on that either.

Yeah i sorta have to agree with sawdust. The club has changed, there's no denying that.

Anyhow i'm already reviewing allot more then i first did when i joined the club. but my reviews are allot shorter then they used to be :P unlike Steph here who hasnt changed a bit xD

btw here's a song i need reviewed :3

Response to Review Request Club Apr 27, 2011


Hello! I have to really thank you guys for helping me get a start on some reviews on my work. Since posting a request a week or so ago, I've seen a lot more constructive criticism on my art. I've been reviewing some of the posted requests on the site and wanted to know how to join. My Reviews

I have also posted a few more art pieces that I would love to have reviewed if at all possible.
http://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/saram ary3/taste
Stripe
Rain

Thank you again!

Response to Review Request Club Apr 27, 2011


Check my response to Lordboy in my above post. That or you could click on my profile then look at my reviews for an example of how to do some reviewing. SuperSteph54 has excellent reviews and then the ex-member AnalPenguinFarming also has excellent reviews that you could check out. They don't have to be that long but 2 or more paragraphs are always nice.

Thank you! I will check them out!

Response to Review Request Club Apr 27, 2011


At 4/27/11 07:30 PM, SCTE3 wrote: 99 points for the week.
closer to 3,000 I see

O.O

Response to Review Request Club Apr 27, 2011


Reviews? Much appreciate guys.

Response to Review Request Club Apr 28, 2011


At 4/26/11 08:05 PM, joeyjoah wrote: And supersteph, what's it like being a mod? (even if you're just a audio mod >:) )

Its liek dis.

Review Request Club


Review Request Club | CHECK THIS OUT | Formerly Supersteph54 | I'm an Audio Moderator. PM me for Audio Portal help.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club Apr 28, 2011


At 4/28/11 08:41 AM, Supersteph54 wrote:
At 4/26/11 08:05 PM, joeyjoah wrote: And supersteph, what's it like being a mod? (even if you're just a audio mod >:) )
Its liek dis.

Oh my god.
That is... so cute.

Oh and, just in case I forget to say my score, I currently have 40 points. Not a ton, but this is my first week in this club. I don't think I'm gonna be able to get 100% of things reviewed, but right now I've got 5 requested reviews completed, with 3 of those having the club signature.


q

Response to Review Request Club Apr 28, 2011


Oops, forgot the 3 points for posting. that's 43 points, and I'm planning on raising that.


q

Response to Review Request Club Apr 28, 2011


At 4/28/11 07:48 PM, SCTE3 wrote:
At 4/28/11 07:23 PM, nconde25 wrote: Thanks guys!! I apreciate it!
I shall review it. Also anything else you want reviewed, feel free to post here or send me a PM.
I always enjoy seeing (1) in my inbox, enjoy writing them reviews :-)

Actually, he's thanking me for my awesome review. But I forgot to put the sig...


q

Response to Review Request Club Apr 28, 2011


At 4/28/11 08:34 PM, SCTE3 wrote: I know. I said " I will review it.", not trying to steal thunder or anything. Also have fun doing reviews as always.
I know I do :P

Oops, now I feel bad.

So guys... wanna talk about the awesome feeling of reviewing? When I see a submission with every review saying 'good' or 'dis sucks', It seems so awesome to write a review with a fair amount of words that mean something.

But I find thinking of a good summary is one of the hardest parts of a review. I usually end up making a lame pun about the title.


q

Response to Review Request Club Apr 28, 2011


Seems rather chatty in here today.

At 4/28/11 08:52 PM, joeyjoah wrote: So guys... wanna talk about the awesome feeling of reviewing? When I see a submission with every review saying 'good' or 'dis sucks', It seems so awesome to write a review with a fair amount of words that mean something.

Only if I write an epic Steph review which i've done maybe 10 times. Usually reviews just flow for me and stack up.


But I find thinking of a good summary is one of the hardest parts of a review. I usually end up making a lame pun about the title.

Sometimes I leave a summary out. It's not always needed.

Response to Review Request Club Apr 28, 2011


Hi, this is my latest song, I would appreciate any tips or advice!

Thanks!


Check my SoundCloud Here!

Response to Review Request Club Apr 29, 2011


At 4/26/11 04:22 PM, SCTE3 wrote:
01 ) 7480 | 1166 / 2074 | 056.22% || 000 | 00 / 10 | 000.00% | Coop ***
02 ) 7287 | 1133 / 2078 | 054.52% || 000 | 00 / 10 | 000.00% | Haggard *
Would be a shame if either dropped off since they are diehards. :C

Ha! Not going to happen! :P


Surf Nazis must die! || Wi/Ht? #38

Response to Review Request Club Apr 29, 2011


Response to Review Request Club Apr 29, 2011


At 4/28/11 09:06 PM, sixflab wrote: Only if I write an epic Steph review which i've done maybe 10 times. Usually reviews just flow for me and stack up.

Haha not only you ;D I've done my share of steph reviews from back when i first joined the club :3 I don't have enough patience anymore tho lol

Response to Review Request Club Apr 29, 2011


Unnamed WIP

Hey guys can you review this please?

Thanks.

Response to Review Request Club Apr 29, 2011


At 4/29/11 07:35 PM, Dj-GST wrote: Unnamed WIP

Hey guys can you review this please?

Thanks.

I did it! :D

Response to Review Request Club Apr 30, 2011


Here you go, ladies and gents. Looking forward to your thoughts.

Response to Review Request Club Apr 30, 2011


Response to Review Request Club May 1, 2011


At 5/1/11 09:22 AM, SCTE3 wrote: First day of May, how is everyone feeling for the new month? Also won't be long until I graduate high school, yay.

Nice, congrats.

Frankly I'm not going to enjoy this month. I have GCSE's till the 23rd, and so far I've only done 6 out of 24 of the exams. But at least my birthday's on the 15th.


Review Request Club | CHECK THIS OUT | Formerly Supersteph54 | I'm an Audio Moderator. PM me for Audio Portal help.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club May 1, 2011


Only a short 57 second segment. Please review :D

Response to Review Request Club May 1, 2011


At 5/1/11 09:47 AM, SCTE3 wrote: Wow, that's a lot of exams!!

Technically I have eleven subjects, but each subject has Paper 1 and Paper 2, and I'm taking two extra exams as a foreign GCSE, making a total of 24, excluding the seven listening comprehensions/oral examinations I had to do too...

But hey, I'll make you bday thread in General when your birthday comes around because you're one of the few people I converse with on here.

That's really awesome, thanks, but I doubt anyone in the General Forum would have a clue who I am :P.


Review Request Club | CHECK THIS OUT | Formerly Supersteph54 | I'm an Audio Moderator. PM me for Audio Portal help.

BBS Signature

Response to Review Request Club May 1, 2011


Well, so much for reviewing everything, I got 43 points. It's not that bad for the first week though. I'd imagine.

I kept getting stumped halfway through audio reviews, even though I listen to a lot of music.


q

Response to Review Request Club May 1, 2011


At 5/1/11 02:01 PM, SCTE3 wrote:
At 4/27/11 07:30 PM, SCTE3 wrote: 99 points for the week.
closer to 3,000 I see
104 points for getting TTT to join us. Looking forward to having a new member here. Guess getting new members is not hard.

Yeah, I heard you guys were getting a little low on members before, but there's always more people that enjoy helping artists. I think that not enough submission authors know about this place though, I've seen submissions with the artist begging for a review and getting four or five one-liners and a word spammer. (of course I end up helping the guy in this scenario)


q

Response to Review Request Club May 1, 2011


At 5/1/11 02:14 PM, ToastedToastyToast wrote: Okay, I started reviewing requested stuff. I am keeping track of my points via a news post and you can see how many points I have earned so far in my sig. Do you need to provide evidence for earning points or not?

As far as I understand, you don't need much evidence. Steph will find your reviews anyway.

Also, you have some nice reviews. Just out of personal preference, you might want to try putting more space in between your paragraphs. I find it more engaging to read.


q

Response to Review Request Club May 1, 2011


I'd like to request a review of this song:

And also I would like to join the review club, I think my reviews are constructive and legible enough.

Thanks!


Die like you were born. Covered in blood and screaming

Response to Review Request Club May 1, 2011


Modern Classical atonal piece. I'm going with the "it is what it is" mentality as far as the composition goes (because I have this theory that logic is what has been preventing my originality), but it would be nice to hear how well you guys think the performance is emulated or how to improve the sound quality.

Response to Review Request Club May 2, 2011


At 5/1/11 03:39 PM, SCTE3 wrote:
Nice audio reviews you got there!

Thanks! Does this count as acceptance to the club?
And if so, do I do the requests that were posted in the last update or do I do the ones that people are posting now, just trying to get into the scoring system a bit, since that's the "application form". . .

And thanks toasty, or whatever it is people around here call you, I appreciate helpful, honest reviews!

Omega


Die like you were born. Covered in blood and screaming

Response to Review Request Club May 2, 2011


At 5/2/11 01:43 PM, Omega-Ravager wrote: Thanks! Does this count as acceptance to the club?

Yep!

And if so, do I do the requests that were posted in the last update or do I do the ones that people are posting now, just trying to get into the scoring system a bit, since that's the "application form". . .

I'm about to do the update now, so you can start when SCTE3 posts the new requests list. Do as many as you want, and when you feel like you've done enough, post the points here in the thread and you're set.


Review Request Club | CHECK THIS OUT | Formerly Supersteph54 | I'm an Audio Moderator. PM me for Audio Portal help.

BBS Signature