Good.
Overall good, but semms like you positioning nazis as heroes of this battle.
Reviews for "Stalingrad 1942"
Sgt-Mac responds:
Hmm... Well it wasn´t my intention. But thanks for review!
I like it.
Great job. only improvements i see could be in the areas of music and Blood.
Nice work!
Great work man! The music was pretty authentic (in spite of it wasn't german or russian) It was only a bit too short. Next time make it a bit longer and you will get a 10/10 from me.
Very Black Comedy
Wow, this is a neat way to portray the war in Stalingrad - sort of like Enemy at the Gates, but without Jude Law's awful acting.
I loved this piece, but it was a little too light on the blood and gore - flashing a red circle up on screen doesn't work for me in showing bloodshed. The corpses which fall to the floor look just the same as when they were alive, so maybe do something about that. Making it suitable for teens is alright, but if you add a little more violence, it's still not going to be as nasty as Madness or Bunnykill.
I'm just after a spot of realism, that's all. We don't want the kids thinking that war's great, because it isn't
[Review Request Club]
Sgt-Mac responds:
I agree with you. This actually started with no blood, and with animation already done, adding bullet wounds would've been pain in the ass.
And by the way, Enemy at the Gates is a great movie.
good
i don't pretend to know much, but i think i get this much, germans are grey and russians are brown helmets. Why are the germans listening to an english song? Very good animation, reminiscent of the Wink series by Gel in the characters. Although i don't recognize any of the major battles of Stalingrad in the scenes, the clip (its pretty short), depicts the mayhem that the whole battle was.
Sgt-Mac responds:
I don't know any german (or russian) songs, and didn't bother to search. Plus I love this song. Thanks for review.