Reviews for Ed's treasure

[Bezman]

working on

++ Pleasant music. Set mood really well.

- Gets mildly irritating though.

++ I kinda liked the simplicity of the levels. Kept it from getting irritating.

!!!! It's possible to get the fish stuck in the walls around the perimeter. If this happense, we just have to wait for a timeout.

!!!! In level 9, on the way to the coin, we seem to be teleported through the wall when we move round the bend just before the coin.

---- Controls for the light were annoying. Way it moves once, stops, then continues as the repeating-majigie kicks in.

---- Lacks any real challenge. Doesn't ever feel like a skillful game - more just a grind. The light doesn't really add any extra skill to the game, just the grind of having to scan the level.

==
Not bad for a first game, but keep working on the game mechanics.

How about you have the level made up of electric eels and when we touch them, we die? At the start of the level, we'd be allowed to see the level for a few seconds. Thereafter, we get to see a single eel whenever we get within a certain distance?

Still not much fun and the bugs seem game-breaking.

Abs55 responds:

Thanks for the review. I'll think about your ideas when I make future games of Ed and I'll try and fix the bugs as best as I can.

[firefox2219]

Not bad

it was pretty good for a first time flash movie. it was entertaining, just try to vary the music and have the light move a bit slower with the arrow keys, it got way ahead of my fish alot overall it was pretty good

Abs55 responds:

Thanks for the review. I'll think about your advice when I make future flash games.

[mikesol1]

Fun but repetitive

Well I started the game off and I must say that for a first time flash game this is pretty good. I liked the menu and the instructions looked cool even though it took me a minute to figure out the real goal of the game. The sound was also good, although it repeated a bit too much for my liking. I also liked the controlability (is that even a word?) of the fish.

However, with that being said, I have some suggestions. First off, I'd maybe add a comment when you first start the game on what to do. Most people don't bother to read the directions and it's confusing if they don't. Perhaps just make a note at the top of they swim off of the light as to the controls? Also, try and diversify the sound a bit. Perhaps make some more sounds or add other fish that swim around. Finally, it seemed a bit too easy. Some other objectives or things to avoid would make the game more challenging.

Nevertheless, the game was enjoyable and it is definitely a good start for a flash-game career. 8/10 =)

Abs55 responds:

Thank you very much for the review. I will add a note or a comment, just when you start the game so you know what to do in the future editions of ed. I will also add the enemies and add sounds in the future.

Thank you again for the good review.

[LightMoon1345]

LOL

No enemies, although I kept swimming onto the black area on the left and right sides, lol.

Abs55 responds:

I am sorry but I don't think you understood the game. The light is movable by the arrow keys so you can look at the environment. The fish can be moved with the mouse. You collect the one coin left in ecah level and return to the treasure helmet to get to the next level.

Thanks anyway for the review.

[tutuman]

if this is ur first not bad if not no good

it get repetive maening boring to fast same thing every level i think u shpuld add sharks and fisher men just take the advice but great game over all.

Abs55 responds:

Thanks for the review. I will add enemies like sharks and other fish in the future editions of ed. But thanks again for the good review! :)