Reviews for Anime Collab

[Coop]

Quantity over quality

If quality was rated as quantity, this would be the best thing I've seen on NG. However, I can say that it is definately NOT that. Don't get me wrong, the animation style is great, the music is a little loud in places, causing static feedback, but the parts all seem a little disjointed.

I viewed it and it looks like a group of like minded animators have had one MSN conversation, gone away for three months and come up with a 2 minute animation, which is tenuously linked to the other pieces.

If you spent more time working as a team, you could get a much more refined article. Perhaps rather than using a music background, you could script and voice it. Then even though the animation style changes, the voices could allow you to differentiate the characters etc.

Not bad, just not as good as I expected from an 11Mb file.

keicho responds:

it was actually 8 months, and 6 minutes run time

[Ectheo]

not bad

some of the artists need some fine tuning, but otherwise most of them show great promise. The one I saw a particular amount of potential is in the one with inuyasha, the actual artwork is not very special, but the seamlessness of the animation was astounding.

PS

I liked the music :)

[K-Devil]

hard to rate with a group of people

i don't like voting a video showing a bunch of other people's animation/drawings together. doesn't really have a story line. i didn't really like the music also. out of all the works, only 3 art works looked amazing to me.

[Maxibility13]

Cool..

Its cool, but its too long.. but there's some bad animation.. anyway, its good!

[Ezraielor]

nice done

nice done, pal's. but as before said, some scenes are just too long, and some are just crap (really, the scene after VHD, was it also VHD? I barely could tell)

Oh, and somethin to mind for all the Deathnote Screamers: Look, when the animation was loaded up, and then subtract 8 months. And then tell me, if Death Note was there a hit allready. Little Hint: The first letter is an N, and the second an O ;)