Good/Bad
T'was a good flash, yet.... with any collab, there will be a few bad ones, okay there still good, but not as good as some of them
anyway, i hope this gets thru, as it is really a very good flash
Reviews for "Anime Collab"
123
nice colab
Slightly dissapointed..
To be completely honest with you, I was personally a little dissapointed with the outcome of the Anime Collab. Not to be bashing you guys or anything, but this was possibly one of the most hyped collabs and it didn't live up to its reputation. I'll go one by one of some of the major animators:
Keicho: I think you did a spectacular job putting this together, good work. Your parts were also very well made. Good job!
Quimera: You were quite dissapointing in my opinion. You have a very 'big' name and you really didn't show your true talent within your pieces. Your chrono trigger scene was especially lacking.
Astropuff: Absolutely stunning!! Great graphics with fluid fbf, good job. I especially loved your pokemon scene. Your inuyasha scene was a bit too sketchy in my opnion though.
British Moose: Your parts seemed the weigh the collab down a little, more time should've been taken to refine your skills.
Mental Myles: Really out of place in this group. Though you really stand out, you seemed to stand out in a negative fashion. I really enjoy your other works though.
Ginilla: This was a great piece. Should've gotten co-author in my opinion. Well made, and well composed.
Genesis Sum: Should've showed off your swift skills a bit more, animation seemed too static.
ForestXion: Needs a lot of work, for a predominantly fbf collab, your animation was way too blocky and choppy.
PimpinJ: Sexy animation, sexy style!
Very nice collab overall though. It was very well put together and the liquid tension music held it together like glue. But its hard to make an anime themed collab because it will obviously be compared to the original anime. But you guys pulled through in the end, good job!
Not bad
The animation was awesome. The Samurai Champloo part blew me away at how close it looked to the show. Very good artists. Some of them are superb, but some of them where blah.
If you make another of these, next time make sure that the comments at the beginning have been spelt check and have subject verb agreement. To get a high scoring collab, they typically have animations that are tied together with the song. This seemed like any song could have been editted with it, and that is not what needs to happen. If it all possible, make a story board so they all connect so it isn't random animations put together.
It's was good!
I loved that there were so many animes that I recognized on your flash. I give mad props to the people who made the flash with you. Good job!