Reviews for Anime Collab

[Kalosoan]

Heh, Decent

I honestly cant see how people get so obsessed over anime. I personally find it to be horrible. Though, I watch it anyway. Animation is an art form afterall.
some of the artists here did quite a good job on most of the animation, like many have said before me, a lot was lacking. Other than the few artists that did very well with movement and animation. There was a couple that did horrible, Sorry to say, but they sort of 'ruined' the collab in a way.
Though, In Collabs. Thats to be expected.
Keep up with the animation.

[Totty]

Pretty terrible.

It's dissapointing when you work really hard or long on something and it just turns out to be crap. I don't know if that's the case with this, but frankly, the material in there wasn't very good. And quite frankly, I tried to review this yesterday but had to close the window because I couldn't think of how to put it.

The art was...well...copied essentially (and before you jump and say 'NAO I DREW DAT ALL MAISELFF!!!1', no, look, if you took a style already done, took characters, titles, and poses from an anime, you copied), and though there were moments of decent movement, overall there was damn little character animation, and what I saw kind of sucked...

I would suggest, quite honestly, not doing so much anime, you various NG artists. Anime is cool, but it's so overdone, and unless you're really good at it and have developed your hand, NOT BY COPYING ANIME, it's probably gonna look like crap. Worse yet, if it looks really good, it still looks like anime, and people will go, oh that's nice, but it's anime so it looks like everything else.

[quikfox1]

it was good

i though that some of the animation blew but then it happened to get good but there were quite a few crappy one i mean like comon plz plz plz take more time (i absloutely loved the gundum seed animation probably the best ive seen

[Orangebeef]

This collab owns.

This was ubelievable when I watched it yesterday, but when I watched it today it wasn't as great. This is still an awesome collab, and it kicks so many asses.

Graphics - Some of the clips deserved an absolute 10, but others weren't quite as "anime" as the absolute 10 ones. Overall, all of the clips get at least an 8 from me.
Style - Collabs are always Styled, and actual Anime submissions are beyond "styled" in style.
Sound - Dream Theater = WIN
Violence - So many clips had violence.
Interactivity - Menu, Scene Selection, Artist Profiles, and Play.
Humor - The awesomeness (???) of some clip's graphics made me laugh, because they were so "anime."

Overall - 10
I rarely give out tens (except for my earlier crap reviews), but this one has got my 10. Also, the Hellsing guy was creepy. You know, the guy in the red clothes, the nice hat and the gun.

[Xyanide]

holy sh*t! o.0

Wow that was great! I liked it from the beginning as soon as the music started (huge fan of dream theater and of course liquid tension experiment) and a fan of anime...i mean who isn't on here :P anyway i watched most of the series that passed in this collab and i loved it. Especially the part hellsing and samurai champloo parts jezus christ that looked as if it was animated by the original animators! perfect job on those!!! Also the 3D kinda gundam part was really amazing. The only thing i missed in here was "gunslinger girl". Oh well i'll definetly be keeping an eye on some of the animators i've seen at work here!