Outstanding...
This game had me in chills the entire time. Especially reading the diary/journal in bedroom. Sometimes I get a bit impatient, the first time I played this game I just skipped through all the journals (same thing I did the first time I played Exmortis 1). I had to come back and play it again, and trust me, the scare factor did not go away. In fact, it probably increased when I actually took the time to read the bone-chilling diary. The story line is incredible, the graphics are great, especially for a flash game.
The only thing I found a bit confusing is the main character. Who is this guy, where is he from, etc. Of course after playing it a second time I paid more attention to detail and found a few things (apparently his wife and child were disemboweled on his front lawn!). But that's just me, I'm more of a plot driven type person, so I like everything to fit together nicely. Still, awesome story.
All in all, this is amazing. I'm almost reminded of Myst, if it was done in flash, and had LOTS more scary-goriness ^^. Keep up the good work!