Reviews for Going Down to Newgrounds

[Thenextbesthang]

OK

I know that the song is not a great one for a video, but here were my problems with ure video.
- It didn't go anywhere. If i remember correctly, there were (2?) verses that were the non chorus. What I look for in a video is some sort of continuince if it is not incredibly high quality in animation. Your video seemed to be "Hey, heres the chorus. Now here's the verse. Here's the chorus again..." Essentially you were reacting to the song, rather than making the song react to you instead. If that makes any sense.
- I don't think that the song has much replay value, of course that probably has to do with my taste in music. It's just not...something that I would watch again. It doesn't overwhelm me with goodness. Like i said before, if the animation was more drastic, and it wasn't repetative, i may decide to watch it again.

Other than that, it was pretty good. The syncronization seemed alright, although it also didn't seem too complicated to do. The animation fit the song. The graphics were...better than I could do. Not that that statement says much anyways.

stoners-lunchbox responds:

Shame you see it that way...

Though you have a point. The animation was good made but it was mainstream... Like you said it went from chorus to verse and back to chorus. I was just trying to fit exactly what the song sang. I don't usually do music videos. The only time i did before this was my "Floor" music video and that was a bit better i guess (probably because the song was actually my own).
The song itself is just a matter of taste... We can only agree to disagree on that one, since you're not a big fan of it, yet i think the song deserves a lot of praise.

Either way, i'll try improving the graphics and for my own sake i won't make another music video for a while.

Well, thanks for the feedback! Yours actually helps!

[AztecJaguarWarrior]

Good song, bad animation.

This was nothing that special to be honest, the music was prety good but the animation was lacking in almost every way. Based on the looks of it, the author hates sticks as well. Stickmen are just shortcuts to avoid having to do much real animation, maybe the author should've done this himself as he obviously made a glorified slideshow with the occaisional neurotic twitch of animated life.

stoners-lunchbox responds:

Obviously you seem like someone who went against me because he thinks we're stick haters... We like sticks, only problem is that we see too many stick animations and half of the ones coming into the portal totally suck. As for your comment about my animation theme, need i remind you that this tribute is also another episode of my Ratbag & Furball series. That's the only reason for which i used those characters in it.

Thanks for the feedback, but it sounded like you didn't have a clue as to what i did and why. Rather than assuming you should ask first. Denvish thought i did a great job with it.