Amazing
Buetiful and magical - your a real talent, you should be making big things for tv.
Amazing
Buetiful and magical - your a real talent, you should be making big things for tv.
Wow!
This has been quite possibly the best work of flash I have ever seen. Great job! I bet you could make alot of money doing this eh? I look forward to the next one.
Extreme cool!
I saw your "Prowlies at the River"
That was cool, but now... thats awesome, the animation is probably one of the best i've ever seen! Its really cool, continue that way!
Make more!
That was awesome... the graphics deserve worship
That was, without a doubt, the greatest effort that anyone has put into a Flash animation as far as I know. You deserve many times as much as I can put in words. There are a few things to improve on, but it would be wrong to say anything bad at all about this. I like it and I usually don't like things that are nonviolent enough to be appropriate for all ages.
Graphics - I'm disappointed... that NG holds me at only at a scale of 0-10. Now I'm regretting giving 7-10 on anything else on NG. If this is a 10, then everything else is below 0 or less. You don't see things this good on TV/DVD. That even beats 3D animation. If I didn't know better, I'd swear that WERE 3D. Unnecessary attention to detail, everything moves, shadows, and almost everything happens as you would expect from real life. There is no way that this gets only 10. Yeah, I said it. ONLY 10. If I wasn't restricted like this, my rating would be about 24/10.
Style - Its very original, and it redefines 2D animation. Moving camera, many camera angles, close-ups, realistic environments, and more. You must have done a lot of research. As far as I can tell, this theme has never been chosen before.
Sound - Good sound. The music suited the occasion/theme, and the sound effects never seemed like they didn't fit. But what I didn't give it a 10 for was the -lack- of sound effects. Sometimes, things would move, but there would be no sound to go with it.
Violence - I'm not going to disrespect you. I understand if you want to keep this 'G-rated', so to speak. I can't give it a 10 to make up for the fact that i can't rate higher for graphics, and I can't give it a 10 because you wanted to keep it appropriate. I also can't give it a 0 because it's not like there was no hostile interaction between the characters. I gave it an average score (5) just because that's what I feel is right.
Interactivity - I'd give it a 0 like most other Flash animations, but the buttons are animated, so i can't do that.
Humor - OK, the 6 isn't because the humor wasn't funny. Its for the fact that there were only 2 funny parts. Now I understand that it's not easy to get a lot of humor in that is 'G-rated', especially in a short movie with such amazing graphics that every frame takes quite a bit of work. But I have to be honest.
Overall, that was beyond 10. Yeah, I know what you people are thinking... "Hey, what's higher than 10...? 10 is perfect!" Yeah, well I've given worse animations 10 before and now I regret it. I'm just scoring it based on comparison to the other ratings I've given. It would be an insult to give this the same score as certain other things. That shattered my perceptions on what is capable with Flash. While this movie may not mean much to me, it stretched boundaries, so to speak. I thank you for that. There is so much that I have to say that I can't put into words. You deserve much better than awards that can only be seen on a computer screen and meaningless reviews from meaningless reviewers like me. This animation is beyond words.
Beautiful
Wow, that's gotta be one of the best flash animations i've seen in a long while... Definately a work of art this one, FBF never looked so good :-)