Spectacular!
Wow, this is such a pretty animation. It has a deep story and moving music. The graphics really portray what you are trying to show. I love it. You must've spent a lot of time on this. Wow, great job. I want to see more.
Reviews for "Autumn Tree"
Incredible...
Wow... just amazing... and EXTREMELY controversial. Graphics and animation were amazing. Sound was ok too. The cop at the end with the megaphone sounded terrible though. Sounded like a kid trying to sound grown-up. But everything was just amazing. The reason I put violence at 0 is because this violence isn't meant to be entertaining, so the violence, although there was some, just didn't apply to that criteria. The violence is not there for me to enjoy, it's for me to understand a point or to display the situation as it really happend, for me at least. I noticed you didn't add the flash to the guns or show any major gory-ness. I find that entertaining sometimes, but not for this kind of flash, so I'm glad you didn't exagerate it like those other crappy flashes that make fun of such a tragic incident. At least you put serious thought and effort to this. Basically, it wasn't made fun of. Really, overall, just amazing. Definatley frontpage worthy by all means. I just hope they don't think it's TOO controversial, but I highly doubt it... being controversial is what NG is all about.
I can't find the words....
I can't express just how.... masterful this flash was done. It sits on a most delicate knife edge: between beauty and tragedy, between the thoughtful and the reckless, between placid calm and terrifying chaos. A masterpiece of animation which portrays the events of Columbine with a fine touch of subtlety. This is not an outright condemnation, nor does it condone what the boys did, but rather it's a call for understanding in a world that has become so very mad and strange.
I wish I could write some more on this but I think I'll go the minimalist route and just leave it here.
Damn.
That was an amazing flash. It's hard to believe something like this can actually happen... I mean, when I went to school, we saw guns all the time, I never stopped to think what would happen if people were bent on shooting. Anyway, great flash... hope to see more like it.
powerfull, i love you art style
Thank you so much. you gave a human edge to a story that became riddled with politics and eventually became a tool to maintain the institution they hated. I look forward to your next project, as always.
Thank you again, ~AloneInTheDark, Andres Ciambotti, and Steven Lawson, you told a Powerful Tale.