Reviews for Autumn Tree

[epyon2142]

You can animate, but poor selection.

Music was decent, no speaking until the end. You can obviously animate, but your selection of what to animate was poorly chosen. It was basically just a fairly boring documentary about a couple of kids who decided to shoot a few people at their school. Even if it did happen, doesn't mean its anything good to animate. Calling a teacher a bitch after shooting him...yea, lets kill the people who have to work for a living because were fuckups, but its not our fault, oh no, nothing is ever your own fault, lets blame the teachers parents and some kids for our failure at life in a nifty little suicide note.... Come on, really, the animations good, the sounds decent, but its really not that great an flash, mainly because what you chose to animate just kinda sucked. Better luck next time.

[GeijutsukaOO]

Elephant

Although i quite like the idea of making a flash animation about columbine seeing how both guys where into drawing and flash. This doesn't tell me anything that has not already been said in a better way. Perticularly in Gus Van Sant's Elephant. Which i'm sure you've seen because you've pretty much reproduced it here. Don't immitate, innovate. Your just reproducing stuff that's already been said and seen.

also speaking facts One of the most interesting to me was that The origonal intention of the masacre was to detonate explosives around the entire premisis (that failed to go off) and was maticulously planned to maxamise the death toll. The intent was to create a catastrophy on a scale never before seen inside America in relation to the admeration they had for the nazi party and mass genocide. And at the end of the day you have a country inwhich people can order a gun to there doorstep. And frankly it was bound to happen, kids usauly act on impulses and if they have easy acess to munitions they ARE going to use them unless there are laws to stop them. There's no way to explain the reasoning for it I agree but there are certainly logical explanations for how to prevent it in the future (or certainly minimise it).

[tino-fairy]

think again...

i'm not impressed with this at all. for such a touchy subject and reading other reviews for it i don't see why you made this flash since apparetly you didn't get the facts straight. yes the style and animation was good but perhaps instead of tryin to portray what actually happened it would have been better to express the feelings felt by the victims and the boys that did the shootings rather than try to recreate what happened. i don't see why you would wish to show the shootings when if anyone that went to the school or knew any of the victims saw this it would be upsttting and distressing. this is NOT art. it is also NOT needed.

[Big-Louie]

UH

You did great animations, great sound, great presentation, but this is kind of a twisted way to use your skills. i dont see why anyone would want to see what went on

[Peacthroviolence]

Good movie, but lots of flaws.

First, let me get to the good points.
- Great anamation (really good)
- Good voice Acting.
- Great tribute to what happened that day.

Now Bad.
-Almost all of the events you depicted in this movie didnt happen the way you made it seem to be. I dont care about motive or anything else, its just that you made scenes about events that never even happened or were just not true. Theres a series that the discovery channel did and its on youtube called Zero Hour that depicts all of the true facts of that disaster and you are wrong about most of what took place that day.

If you are mad and want more evidenc, let me know and I will be more than happy to carry this on.