Reviews for Autumn Tree

[Dray013]

...hmm

I had a tough time grading this one... One side is telling me that people should stop making flashes that bring up old tragedies again, and the other is telling me if you didn't want to watch it, then you shouldn't have in the first place. So putting both of those feelings aside, I graded this solely on the animation and put the story of it behind.

Graphics- Your animation was pretty good and ran for the most part pretty smooth. The guy running though was pumping the wrong arm at the wrong time, but I consider graphics to be only visual clarity and motion instead of how stupid a guy runs... 10

Style- All you did was take a tragedy and remake it, and apparently gave someone some purple hair who didn't really have any... 0

Sound- The music quality was good, and a decent choice for the type it was I guess, but the voice overs were of poor quality... 6

Violence- Yeah, there was blood, but not as violent as let's say, Bunny Kill... 7

Interactivity- movie... 0

Humor- About a tragedy...0

Overall- Putting the feelings of remaking a story of a tragedy, which I personally think is a horrible thing to do (like the "tear for london" which was made the day the bombing took place) I grade the animation a 5. It moved along really slowly, the whole part that happened in the school, which was I thought the whole point of this, took place in the last like minute of this I think 5-6 minute animation. They walked really slowly, everything just seemed slow. I don't know if you guys have made anything else, but try putting your animation techniques into something new and original instead of bringing back past miseries, k?

[Normer]

Too long!

It was a little too long. Some of the artwork was lacking as well. However, I did like the music.

[Phoenix009]

Ain't really that deep. Just muder scenes.

all these people reviewing this say it extremly deep blah blah blah. It isn't. Your characters have no emotions. If your going to make a flash based on a real tradedy you should do your best to capture the emotions of it. The graphics were ok but the music was really good. All in all it was ok. I don't like how almost anyflash no matter how bad can get 10's if its based on a tragedy.

[Doktor-Lizard]

Hmm.

Kind of a less effecting version of the film "Elephant" with less style and despite the change in perspective, compared to the flm this was only half as successful at creating any kind of atmosphere.
Not terrible by any means.
The work put into this shows. But, it's a very difficult subject to tackle with any kind of real creative spark when it has been done much better in a different medium not very long ago.
Still looks as good as the effort put into it. It just didn't effect me.
Someone is really going to have to blow up with some kinda masterpiece if they ever want to approach this event again.

[Liamski-Noir]

I realy didn't like this one

At first when i read the other reviews i thought yeh this looks a good Flash and the icon looked good art work so i thought i'd give it a try in the first minuite of the FLash i had to switch it off though i bore me to death there was apsolutly no point of putting the fist part in it was a waste of the animators time and a waste of mine.If i were the animator i would just spice up the start and submit it again. besides the start i liked it. (no offence intended just trying to better your work if this has offended the animator in any way please contact me so i no to dull it down abit)
+
I realy liked the loader bar and screen it was realy clean (if you no what i mean)