Reviews for Autumn Tree

[Da-Votah]

Sorry to hear you got second place

What I think this film lacked was ambiguity. I think it would've been better if the audience wasn't quite sure what the kids were going to do at the beginning. And you should've gone on with the 'is there a god' talk. I think the shooter should've said: "When you go to bed tonight, don't thank god you're still alive. Thank me for not shooting you." Something like that.

Overall it left a chill down my spine, which doesn't happen everyday with flash animations on Newgrounds. I hope this gets a permenent spot in the toons section of the site.

[BillDoor]

Good movie

I agree with the authors, they _did_ include a lot of the important stuff. This is supposed to be a concept, a movie, not a fucking biography. So they only showed one bathroom fight. He didn't seemed shocked by it, so clearly it's happened before, and it openned way to their friendship. This isn't supposed to take an hour long, it was very well made.
The music was great, and I liked how even though the two were so committed to their plan, the music and the way they looked around their homes one last time made me want to bail the plan and just stay home.
Nice flash video in any case, and ignore the 12 year olds who have no clue what they're talking about.

[tits-all-good]

Was Good.

You did alot of things right on this. One thing though i didn't like. You went soft on the reason They commited these murders. You Should of did like a montage of them getting bullied. I know you don't just crack after one beat down. As for everything else like what they did i don't know i wasn't there, yours was the best guess yet.

[HiniberusDelius]

Perhaps not all of them should have died

Although, I will say that the jocks and wiggers/gangsters should (if they had the latter in the town) Jocks have always been assholes and only beg when they're fucked in a situation such as this. As for wiggers, well we don't need gangster scumb anywhere really. Then again that's just me and I will say that what they did was wrong, had I been one of the shooters I'd have gone strait for the jocks and other dipshit that fucked me up. Teachers too if they where abuseive ect.

Again, what they did was wrong and such acts should be punished for the innocent lives lost.

[BearMan2]

Okay..

Nice flash and animaton =)

For the most part it was quite accurate....
VodKAs revenge, basement tapes, ect...

But he wore a shirt that said NATURAL SELECTION
I still remember the day..I was too young to under stand =S

This shit makes me so sad ='(