powerful
this was a very powerful flash, showing the other sied of the carnage. the music followed the subtleties of the artwork perfectly
Reviews for "Autumn Tree"
I -really- liked that a lot...!
That was really good. I liked how you took a serious topic and created an animation out of it -without- over dramatizing it. It subtle, and serious, and done very well. I whole-heartidly(sp) encourage you to create more art. Hope you enjoyed making it as much as I enjoyed watching it. Thank You.
Started off well but ended badly
I think the first half of the movie was really good. I thought you were using imagery and music well to convey what was going on rather than relying on dialogue. Then when the voices started I think it all fell apart. Especially when they were talking like action movie characters. Maybe the real Columbine kids did say "bitch" after killing a teacher, or "Hahaha, natural selection" after shooting some students, but that could have been left out of the movie or acted out in a more dramatic way. And some of the voice acting, like the cop outside almost made me laugh.
The animation was really nice though, and I like your choice of music for the film; it fit well. I'm giving this a 7 overall for the technical quality, but even that's pushing it a bit, because the ending was so appalling (not because of the violence, but because of the voices).
Looking forward to seeing more of your work.
hum :/
"tsss August 5, 2005
Reviewed by: rbc_max Overall Score: 1
A little more and we would think that these guys were heros... "
He's right, the animation might be good but the way you show the story you could think : "you can't blame them" which lower your actual score on your movie.
Reconstruction is not what you think they were doing, but true fact that actually happened.(for some scenes)
++
i liked it
i did the same thing but got stoped