Too long!
It was a little too long. Some of the artwork was lacking as well. However, I did like the music.
Reviews for "Autumn Tree"
Elephant
Yeah, it was good, but it was ripped right out of Elephant. I mean, the names you used weren't even the real ones, just the ones from elephant. And it's not exactly what happened (with the failed bombs and whatnot) but still very good overall.
Fuckin' Beatiful...
But there shouldn't of been any dialogue.
pretty good
I noticed hoever that it pretty much just copied the movie elephant, on it's perspective of the whole incident
Stunning
Beautiful piece of work,well done placing the references to the film "elephant".Not only have you captured the wrong suburban resoning "Your different and that bad" but also the misunderstood boys who have been lashed at for being different,they crush the american dream.
Starting and ending with the question "why?" leaves an big impact on the victims and the rest of america but not why the boys did what they did but *why* the shootings happened in the first place.The boys were wrong but for the right reasons.
NB: I am shocked that other reviewers only took interest in the plot rather than the moral,imagery and how the short film was made.
haha sorry im in critic mode