Reviews for Autumn Tree

[Doktor-Lizard]

Hmm.

Kind of a less effecting version of the film "Elephant" with less style and despite the change in perspective, compared to the flm this was only half as successful at creating any kind of atmosphere.
Not terrible by any means.
The work put into this shows. But, it's a very difficult subject to tackle with any kind of real creative spark when it has been done much better in a different medium not very long ago.
Still looks as good as the effort put into it. It just didn't effect me.
Someone is really going to have to blow up with some kinda masterpiece if they ever want to approach this event again.

[Troy-W]

It was pretty good.

The art style was very well done.
But the storyline was very similar to the movie "Elephant".
Was that intentional?

[NoNameTheOrc]

Skillfully done.....

Good job, but it did seem to lighten up the fact of what these kids did, almost seeming like you were trying to present a justification. No matter what was done wrongly to these kids, their wrongful actions were much worse. Murder never equals alienation, and I know how it feels to be severely alienated. Nevertheless, very impressive.

One thing to add, you may want to do a little touch up editing to the Author's Comments. Simple things like on the 2nd sentence, may want to change the word "were" to "was" being that it is used singularly, "uncomprehendable" isn't a word, you want "incomprehensible."

Grammar in the introduction is so important when presenting a serious work.

[manub2000]

I shed a Tear....

It was amazing. Not since 1999, have I even given the incident much thought. Watchinf your movie reminds me that we live in a sick and twisted world. If only we could learn to accept everyone, not necessarily like them, but accept who they are, and respect them as human beings. If we cannot do that, then what good are we? Man, the movie was simply amazing. Graphics and sound was just great. I especially love how minimal voices were used, and only in key moments. Great use of only showing violence when necessary and not trashing the emotion. It was like watching the whole thing unfold!

[DragonKnightLeader]

Well done

This was really more a wort of art than a movie, so it's better to think of it that way when observing it. The only flaw was that the motive wasn't as well expressed as it could have been, but it flows pretty well.