Reviews for Battle for Gondor

[Dacheater]

Good, with a bit of work this could be awesome

As people have mentioned, their needs to be more this game than just peon slaying and sending out your troops after they die.
I think you should have it so that you can send multiples of the same troops, as this would drastically increase the stratergy. You should have some units that are strong and weak agisant certain troops, and troops that work better in diffrent situations. Wizards are way too expensive, and dwarfs and Knights of Rohan are way overpowered. As others have suggested, I think the hero should have a health bar and be allowed to fight,but as an intresting element you should keep the Peons in so you have to choose between protecting the line (while getting cash) or helping your buds.
It was nice how you made the effort to include a variety of missons, but the game still got a little monatous at times. A password/save feature would be good. I feel their should be an option to minmize the text box, as on the 3rd map, i would often hear fighting and not be able to see what was going on.
The bosses added a nice variety to the game (particurly the spellcaster and the demon) but I thinkthose missons were flawed, because you'd just make a huge gangbeat to take out the boss, and you'd either die, or kill the boss and get so much cash that you just flatten all the enemys on that level into the dirt (with the exception of level 6(my favourite), but you still got way too much cash).
Overall, nice game, if you make a sequal and fix these faults it will be one of the greatest games on Newgrounds

[Michelangelo]

solid

the game is way too monotonous
and repititive. plus for an action
themed game, what is the point
when your army is doing the dirty
work for you, as you yourself take
on a few that pass by. even though
towards the end it does get better,
with more characters to chose from
and more enemy types. plus the difficulty
increases with the lack of money to get
the right militia to take on the masses,
which gives an incentive to kill faster.
though some may give up trying to
accomplish this, if the begining part
wasnt so slow paced.
score: ***
MJ

[Bowserkvn]

its good but it's missing things...

you have the makings of an awesome game but there are things missing in it, how to place my finger on it, well it gets kinda boring and i think your hero should be able to die/fight with the normal units, give your hero the ability to die/level up/learn new skills other than the over the head chop you into 2 pieces sandwhich making technique, it's alright and it did deserve front page but onlu because of originality other than that unless there are some dramatic changes made this won't be much to look at.
thanks...

[smokeshow]

Pretty fair

It could have been better. The way they swung their swords was annoying. It looked like some semi retarded person was wielding it, it did not look convincing and especially not lethal. It was kind of pointless just to click buttons and whatch the computer controlled characters battle below, while your only control was to move the hero and slash those pointless peons.

It got boring. It wasn't a bad idea but could have been exectued better.

[skillet09]

pretty good but not fun

I think the game could improvwe on how fast you attack and you should let the heo run everywere. not very fun ether but it kept me busy for 5 mins 7/10