Reviews for Battle for Gondor

[Napkin23]

AUTHOR: PLEASE READ!!!!

Your game has huge promise, but it is fundamentally flawed in that it is not so much as a game, as it is watching a movie and pushing buttons to keep it going. There is no true strategy as you get constant money and keep having to pump out guys to keep it going, and eventually they will win.

Truly, this game would be great if the commander had to fight to tip the scale, that would actually make this a game. Have enemies come out of all areas, as well as your own men, and you could also have things such as guard towers and what not. That would be very fun.

As it is, it gets extremely monotonous, the only entertaining thing is seeing a new ally or enemy now and then. The little "kill the peon" side game does NOT equal extra challenge or entertainment, just annoyance.

I hope this was helpful critizism (sp) because this game could truly be so much more.

[HateKing]

Really good but....

this was a really good game. good job my friend. nuce. but the only thing the last level, is a little too hard. just about impossible too beat. i got 2 admit i was pissed when i got 2 the last level and had 2 start all over. that's the only thing u should change. u shouldn't have 2 start all over after u die. other than that good job.

[KOSSwifty]

Nice

That is a cool game hope you make more of those good luck

[Michelangelo]

solid

the game is way too monotonous
and repititive. plus for an action
themed game, what is the point
when your army is doing the dirty
work for you, as you yourself take
on a few that pass by. even though
towards the end it does get better,
with more characters to chose from
and more enemy types. plus the difficulty
increases with the lack of money to get
the right militia to take on the masses,
which gives an incentive to kill faster.
though some may give up trying to
accomplish this, if the begining part
wasnt so slow paced.
score: ***
MJ

[Samurai-MX]

Nice Job!

I really enjoyed the game, I actually finished it lol. There were some levels which were really difficult, like the red dragon one, and the magician one. And also the rock. The game was pretty good though, its a little addicting.