Reviews for The Child That Smelt Odd

[sscotch]

Well done, but not my favorite...

This was a very well done cartoon. However, it lacked a real originality that I've come to love in your other work -- it felt like I was just watching South Park, and not David Firth. There were no laugh-out-loud moments for me. And while the points are interesting and insightful -- they didn't feel like anything new. Again... I felt the South Park influence a little too strongly. I'm a sucker for Spoilsbury, Salad Fingers... and especially Roof Tiling (that blew me away!!! Another Paper-flash please!). I miss the freaky Firth. This 'toon feels too lesson-ish.

[Mk200114]

An odd title for this sorta theme.

Or is it vice-versa? Anway, I think this is one of the many flash movies I can actually call "full-length" A.K.A. "complete"! I have to give you props for that. Some bits were slow, but it had just the right amount of humor in it. Very well done!

[smokinbubbles]

alright

i say this was alright, not the best done by you but it was alright. just didn't laugh really in this one. good job on the graphics though.
J-Rod

[TheBigDawg]

Well...

I'm not saying this is bad. I just didn't find it laugh-out-loud funny. Animation was well done, as were voices and music.

The humor is sort of like...um..."Robot Chicken" (Adult Swim on Cartoon Network) humor. Funny but not enough to make me burst out laughing (with the exception of the commercial where a kid gets checked by a hockey player face-first into a urinal. That made me burst out laughing.)

-
w00f.
-

[Triple-Zero]

Twisted

To me that was even more disturbing than your usual stuff. Very witty and subtle social commentary. It would be a bizzare reality...