Absolutely amazing
Only two things that could have been better. The dialogue seemed a little forced. As though the voices weren't really into their roles. And second, the fighting was a little too video game-esque, and in a story that deals with a serious topic, it diddn't seem to fit quite right.
I loved it.
I wanted to faint. This movie was great! :) Definatley one of my favorites. The style was great and I just love the way this movie turned out. Keep it up. :) [Wow. Tha Zampsta just Reviewed you good!] (What the hell is so special about that?) [Shut up, Bob.]
--That was Random!--
Pretty sweet...
Graphics: The only reason I gave you an 8 was because of the swords. Everything was beautifully done but the swords just seemed, well, out of place in their lack of quality.
Style: You seem to have your own unique style, and it shows in the way everything sort of flows together. I especially like the way you handle shapes [<- wierd comment, but hey, thats me...]
Sound: Its good, maybe more than good, but it didn't grab me.
Violence: The gore was what it needed to be. I'm not one for cramming as much violence as possible into any given scene, and while you *do* have your moments, you don't seem to rely on them to carry you through.
Interactivity: n/a
Humour: Meh, its not a comedy...
Overall: Very well thought out. I got a good feeling from it, and although it was rather long [compared to most flashes] it didn't bore me at all. The story was nice, the violence was appropriate, the characters were more or less believable, and it was generally a good sword-swinging time! Nice.
Wow, very nice
I gave you a 10 for style, perfect, i dont know how u came up with this stuff, the ending was incredible. Your ideas r magnifivent. you must have spent a very long time on this movie. it's great
The graphics were incredible but the people, 'eh they were alright
The sounds was awesum, the flashbacks and the voices of the guys fallin comrads, very touching. loved the music because it flowed nicely with the overall theme
The fights arn't the best i've been and there could b more violence, but in this movie, that violence wasnt needed, w2g.
GOOD JOB MAN! Keep up the work! I will never forget this flash! and thats sayin sumthin!
Pure work of genius
Out of all the Flash animations I have seen, this has got to be one of the most unique in presentation. Rather than showing everything that happened, you portrayed them symbolically. For example, rather than having the main character tell us about the horrors of his comrades being slain, you represented the horror using faint pictures and agonizing moans. That gasp and facial expression during the fight against the centaur speaks much more than if he said "I don't want to fight you, my darling!" A definite 10 in style for such a great presentation.
The graphics were, unfortunately, somewhat average. Although I understand how difficult it is to portray dynamic animation using more tweens than frame-by-frame, it made the posts seem static. Nonetheless, the graphics were better than many flash movies on NG, and the movie gets a solid 9 there.
It might be a little better if you improved the voice acting a bit, since they sometimes sound bland and emotionless (especially the moans during the flashback). The music was used really well, but the average voice acting lowered the "Score" score to a seven.
I don't think I really need to explain my other ratings. Either way, due to the presentation alone, this flash animation is a work of genius. I certainly will look forward to more animations from you in the future.
Good luck :).