Reviews for A Christmas Carol

[Craptacular]

Jesus Christ! THE SONG IS BALLS!!

What possessed you to use that melody!?! The animation is good, but the song makes me want to kill myself. It's like you gave someone who knows the book a guitar, and they tried to cram the whole thing in the song that they made up on the spot. Jamming sentences into the same song structure makes the song sound immature, and the same melody over and over and voer and over and over, damn. OVER AND OVER AND OVER!!!! Made me angry....very angry. You don't even know. Please Kritian, Never again. PUT THE GUITAR DOWN. Or at least the microphone. If it was just the music, I'd be ok. But now my wrists are slit. What a great christmas you gave me!

shagrat responds:

You should seek some help for that problem.

[DraculaHunter7]

Ahhh!

The music was good at first... but it was too repeditive of a song. I would of had a course... or just something that didn't have the exact same sound... Besides that, I notice few flaws. Exelent job, and a merry christmas to you.

[artificial]

Good

Nice, well an intresting intro with the Cemetary and fog affects it added the affects of the theme well. The animations were greatand the characters animations were in a original style and the song went with the ghost of the christmas past. This was a neat music vedio with fear,confusion, and even some creepy images, The backrounds were well detailed and the shading was great, also the winter snow affects and lights were solid. This was a great music vedio with the scrouges visits but with creative animations and images.

Amazing work and an impressive christmas humble film with a strong plot and a unique well done ending.

shagrat responds:

Thanks for the feedback. Yea the intro is attempting to capture some of what you get from the work that inspired this.

[Moocod]

Hurray!!

Hurray! That was good. I would have given it a 10 if the lyrics were read or somthing. That song was awful and bland. Each line followed the same melody and it was a horrible melody! When I turned off the sound it was fine :)

[SketchMichaels]

Nicely done!

Hey, that was really neat! A nice adaptation of a familiar tale. Great job, looks like you put a lot of effort into this... and it was well worth it. :)