00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

WilliamTheStrange just joined the crew!

We need you on the team, too.

Support Newgrounds and get tons of perks for just $2.99!

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

Clean up the Portal

1,490 Views | 19 Replies

Clean up the Portal 2007-02-14 13:14:59


Isn't it about time that we raise the requirement for a flash passing through the portal. For me I would think it a no-brainer, but day in and day out we have allowed the likes of kitty krew barney bunch etc. to get the best of Ng. I hate seeing stuff like the ones that have passed with scores like 1.67/5. I don't think it's very respectful of the freedom NG gives its authors. Besides those obvious reasons here are some other factors.

Flash Quality.
With flash 8 out and flash 9 soon coming, it is now easier to make better looking flashes more quickly. I remember a quote Tom made on the front page while "Prowlies at the River" was still there. "The bar for flash has been raised." Indeed it had, but I think along with more quality flash came more people who either decided to have their little groups where they could pass each one off because of a good intro followed by crap. It isn't right. Like socio-economics it has created a gap between the amount of hard-worked ones and complete crap.

Experience/Vote Inflation.
I think it's also time to realize that like how we usually only raise the minimum wage to keep up with inflation, we need to raise the score. Groups like star syndicate (there not all bad) have made a living off getting a high level with lots of voting power, then passing their crap through the portal. It's gotta stop.

Encourage N00bs
A raise in the minimum requirement will encourage more n00bs at flash to rwork hard on their first flashes more, showcase it in the flash forum first more, and be more satisfied in the work they've done. Though I think we've been catering to n00bs and other makers of inconsistant flash by having not all the flashes count towards the batting average. There should be those kind of dents in our average to motivate us to work harder.

Let's try at least raise it to 2.0 or maybe even go so far as 2.25

/rant

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-14 13:19:20


Yeah I do agree on the part that we need to raise the "score" level to atleast 2.0, iv seen some of the most crapiest flashes pass through the portal with 1.60.


XDeeZeroZero4Two-thousand six.

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-14 13:20:45


But KK and other spam group Flashes will be mass voted through anyway like usual.

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-14 13:22:06


yah the score should be raised abit to like 2.00 and stop people like the kk spamming


BBS Signature

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-14 13:26:53


NO! I love the flash portal's shit movies! Thats the only reason I go to the portal.


BBS Signature

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-14 13:28:38


At 2/14/07 01:26 PM, Aliensandwich wrote: NO! I love the flash portal's shit movies! Thats the only reason I go to the portal.

Lies! All are lies.


BBS Signature

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-14 16:35:44


At 2/14/07 01:26 PM, Aliensandwich wrote: NO! I love the flash portal's shit movies! Thats the only reason I go to the portal.

There are no more good crap flashes. The days of dragonball N are over.

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-14 16:41:02


Nice ideas in all. Just use this thread to express them.
http://www.newgrounds.com/bbs/topic.php?id=28 4460

I'm neutral on the matter though. If you raise the score, people will just accommodate as necessary. Then you'll be right back where you started.


NG Review Moderator // Pm me for Review Abuse

BBS Signature

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-14 17:04:00


ya im tired of it too, it needs to be raised to 2.50 too many bad movies


Steam: Bstuk

BBS Signature

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-14 17:05:01


You're right about a bunch of things here. I've believed for quite a while that 1.60 is simply too low a requirement. Like you suggested, I think 2.00 is the perfect number.


Find a mountain to stand on.

BBS Signature

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-14 17:16:36


Raising the score is problematic in one aspect. If 90% of the flashes fail to make it past judgement (right now roughly 50% to 75% of flashes fail to do so), then it will encourage autovoters to vote 0 on everything.

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-14 17:34:44


ya... its not a good idea to raise the standards for flashes to pass thru a portal, we need to keep the requirment of passing judgment at 1.60/5.00


http://xat.com/thetoc2_hangout promoting guitar hero world tour, save up to 20% when you pre-order here

BBS Signature

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-14 21:48:31


Sorry guys but I am just sick of flashes that end up getting 1.2 or something and NOT getting turd of the week. It's ridiculous. The point is is that we wnat to inspire kids who are learning flash to practice before sending their stuff here, wasting our time by voting it and theirs by submitting a flash which they thought was good but isn't.

Also, there are rules for auto-voting. I've been banned because I've done that 0 and 5 thing for so long.

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-14 21:49:53


I agree, I think the minimum should be like 2-3/5. And, if anything allready in the portal drops below that, AUTOMATIC BLAM!

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-27 13:01:04


I agree about raising the minimum for a flash to pass to 1.8 or 2.
That would be a first improvement. And a second one could be to raise the minimum of votes for a flash to pass the judgement. Right now, it's 200. If we raise it to 250 or 300, KK or SS could massively vote 5 on their flash, it might not be enough to make them remain on the portal.

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-27 13:17:22


this won't change anything the movies will still pass just like before even if the passing score was 2.00 or 2.25.

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-27 13:28:43


But then Newgrounds would be all perfect all the time. Something is nothing if they don't have something to yell at.

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-27 13:29:45


i dont care what u raise the score to
i will never get in anyway ;P
i got 3 flashes blammed =D

Response to Clean up the Portal 2007-02-27 13:31:52


This topic has been done to death man.
We all know, with the coming of a new "crew" all the noobs crap their pants and think spam flashes are the greatest thing in the world, and the crew stays around for a while.

But what usually happens is, the crew slips or w/e, and stops for about a month, and when they come back, no one remembers them and their flashes start to get blammed :S


REAL TALK: you better go get a glass of orange juice & spill it all over yourself likea big dumb baby before i tear through your hymen like a dog tears through a piece of meat

BBS Signature