At 8/30/10 09:01 PM, Cericon wrote:
Actually, my art teacher has a rule against anime.
So? It's a popular style, most art teachers want to encourage individual styles.
Because of how easy it is to draw. And he was right.
No, you still have to get the anatomy right. As someone who's seen a lot of bad anime fanart, I can attest anime style isn't all that easy.
You can look at two anime pictures, and sure there are some differences, but it will usually look alike.
Yes, because all superhero characters have wildly different anatomies. Oh wait no. Anime, as cartoons in general, has an uniform style, because it's craft, not art. When you write a serialized comic, or animate a series, you need a consistent style.
From the animes that I've watched (Samurai Champloo, Desert Punk, .Hack, etc) they've all looked very similar in drawing style.
Again. it's a style. Like American Superhero Comics. Or Franco-Belgian comics. It's based on the notion of a pseudo-realist body model. Correct proportions with some exagurated features (mostly, the eyes). And what about the style of Osamu Tezuka? It's the origin of the Anime style, but still different from the modern works. Or if you can't see the fdifference, well, I can't take your claim of having some objective eye for art seriously.
It's not supposed to be an art revolution. it's supposed to tell a story. A human-looking character is easily relatable.
But this is all silly. Why do we have to awnser to this? I mean, this is the anime club, not the bitch about anime club. Go try your luck in general or something. It's not our job debate you on something as subjective as art quality. You can just set up a strawman and call us weeaboos who worship all things Japanese and it's all that's in our lives (in which case I'd invite you to come live a day in my life and then make assessments about my knowledge of art). You're not interrested in reaching anything with coming here and being a dick, you just want to piss people off.